D.A. Henderson's Smallpox Eradication Insights

Apr 14, 2025

Lecture Notes: D.A. Henderson on Smallpox Eradication and Biosecurity

Introduction to D.A. Henderson

  • Distinguished scholar at the Center for Biosecurity.
  • Founding director at the center.
  • Key roles in public health:
    • Director of the Office of Public Health Emergency Preparedness post-Anthrax attacks (2001).
    • Associate Director, Office of Science and Technology Policy for President Bush.
    • Dean, Faculty of the School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins.
    • Director of the Smallpox Eradication Program.
    • Chief of Surveillance Section, Epidemiology Branch, CDC.
  • Awards: Presidential Medal of Freedom, National Medal of Science, National Academies of Sciences Public Welfare Medal, Japan Prize, among others.
  • Authored books on smallpox.

Smallpox Virus Destruction Debate

  • Background: Debate on whether to destroy smallpox virus stocks, with intense political and diplomatic implications.
  • Global Discussions: WHO resolution in 1976 recommended destruction or transfer to select laboratories (CDC, Atlanta; Moscow).
  • Lab Incidents: Accidents in laboratories highlighted the risk (1975 in Munich; 1978 in Birmingham).
  • Current Status: Only two known laboratories retain the virus (USA and Russia), with ongoing debates about destruction.
  • WHO Involvement: WHO committee in 1980 began assessing the need for research and the virus's fate.
  • Developing Countries' Stand: Strong advocacy for destruction due to past burdens of smallpox.

Research and Security Measures

  • Virus Destruction Attempts: U.S. and USSR discussed destruction post-genomic sequencing in 1993.
  • International Consensus: Most countries and virologists favored destruction. Research protocols under international oversight.
  • Vaccine Production Challenges: Post-9/11, the U.S. focused on rebuilding vaccine stockpiles due to bio-terrorism fears.
  • Strategic Planning: Need for strategic plans to handle possible outbreaks, including vaccine distribution and public education.

Ongoing Research and Strategic Concerns

  • IOM Reports (1999, 2010): Evaluated the potential loss of scientific information if the virus were destroyed.
  • Vaccination Strategies: Discussions on the production of vaccines with minimal side effects and antiviral development.
  • Current Capabilities: Evaluation of state and city readiness for mass vaccination campaigns.

Implications of Virus Eradication

  • Rinderpest: Anticipation of a formal announcement of eradication by OIE and FAO.
  • Lessons from Smallpox: Importance of careful certification and cautious announcement of disease eradication.
  • Preparedness for New Viruses: Need for proactive strategies to deal with future viral threats.

Questions and Concerns

  • CDC and DOD Plans: Availability of response plans for smallpox, including ring vaccination strategies.
  • National Response Framework: Issues with existing scenarios and the need for updated strategic plans across agencies.
  • Global Cooperation and Future Threats: Concerns about preparedness for future viruses similar to smallpox.