Real People Keep Getting Re-traumatized: The Human Cost of Binge-Watching True Crime Series

Overview

• Mindy Pendleton's stepson's murder featured in Netflix docuseries "I Am A Killer."
• Concerns about show glorifying the killer, Lindsay Haugen.
• Series aired despite family's emotional pleas against it.
• True crime's impact on victims' families.

Family Reactions

• Mindy Pendleton opposed the show; worried about glorification of the killer.
• Netflix aired the show despite objections.
• Family members refused participation; felt re-traumatized.
• Emotional impact detailed with the last height mark of Robert Mast on a wall.

True Crime's Popularity

• True crime genre gaining traction globally, especially in the US.
• Driven by shows like "Serial," "Making a Murderer," and "The Jinx."
• Millions consume true crime via TV, podcasts, streaming services.
• COVID-19 pandemic increased true crime consumption.

Audience Engagement

• True crime fans include a significant proportion of women.
• Genre seen as offering predictability and justice.
• CrimeCon and similar events show high participation.
• Potential for positive impact, e.g., solving crimes.

Psychological & Social Aspects

• Some view true crime as a way to explore flaws in the justice system.
• Provides distraction and certainty during uncertain times.
• True crime has historical roots in stories like Jack the Ripper.
• Media evolution has made true crime more accessible.

Ethical and Emotional Impacts

• Victims’ families often suffer as stories are retold.
• Families have little power to stop productions.
• Shows may renew public interest in cold cases, but also open old wounds.

Case Examples

• Rosalee Clark's family tragedy retold in a book, resulting in renewed grief.
• Media often focuses on sensational details rather than victim's full life.
• Clark and Pendleton emphasize richer stories than those shared by media.

Concerns & Reflections

• Increase in true crime content raises questions about the balance between storytelling and sensitivity.
• Victims' families advocate for more control over media portrayals.
• Debate over the intentions of true crime productions – advocacy vs. sensationalism.
• True crime content can lead to unintended consequences for victims' families.

Conclusion

• True crime continues to captivate audiences, but at a cost to those connected to the real events.
• Ethical considerations and family consent remain key issues in the production of true crime content.