Language Loss and Global English Impact

Sep 12, 2024

Notes on Language Loss and Globalization of English

Introduction

  • Speaker has lived and taught in the Gulf for over 30 years.
  • Discussion on language loss and the globalization of English.

Personal Experience

  • Anecdote about a friend teaching English in Abu Dhabi.
    • Took students to the garden to learn nature vocabulary.
    • Learned Arabic names and uses of plants from students.
    • Knowledge passed down from grandparents and great-grandparents.
  • Importance of intergenerational communication.

Language Loss Statistics

  • A language dies every 14 days.
  • English as the global language:
    • Rapid rise in the use of English worldwide.

Historical Context

  • First teaching experience in Kuwait:
    • Recruited by the British Council to teach English in state schools.
    • Aimed to modernize and empower citizens through education.
    • UK benefitted from oil wealth.

Evolution of English Teaching

  • Teaching English has shifted from a mutual benefit to a major international business.
  • English is no longer limited to native speakers (e.g. UK, US).
  • Demand for English education due to the best universities being in English-speaking countries.

Gatekeeping in Education

  • Language proficiency tests as barriers to education:
    • Non-native speakers must pass tests to enter universities.
    • Question of fairness in rejecting students based on language alone.
    • Example: Would reject a brilliant non-English speaker?
  • Danger of Power:
    • Concerns about giving too much power to English teachers.

Translation and Historical Context

  • Importance of translation in history (Islamic Golden Age).
  • Questions around the self-fulfilling prophecy of English being the dominant language in research.

Critique of English as a Barrier

  • Criticism of equating intelligence with knowledge of English.
  • Historical figures like Einstein did not have English requirements.
  • Language tests (e.g. TOEFL) can be prohibitively expensive for many.

The Great Divide

  • Education as a dividing line:
    • Desire for English education stems from wanting better job opportunities.

Collaboration Across Languages

  • Story about two English scientists needing a German colleague to solve a problem:
    • Different languages can offer new perspectives and solutions.
  • Personal anecdote about the speaker's daughter:
    • Studied Science and Mathematics in Arabic, excelled after translating into English.

Consequences of Language Death

  • Importance of preserving languages to avoid losing knowledge and ideas.
  • Example of a Kenyan boy who invented a solar lamp for his village:
    • Highlighted the potential of individuals when resources are provided.

Conclusion

  • Call for celebrating diversity in language and thought.
  • Encouragement to use language as a tool for sharing ideas and progress.