Key Differences: Catholic vs. Protestant Christians

Sep 15, 2024

10 Differences Between Catholic and Protestant Christians

Introduction

  • Video requested by viewers.
  • Focus on differences in doctrines.

1. The Split

  • Origin of Catholicism: Began with Jesus Christ's teachings in the 1st century CE.
  • Catholic view: Continuation of the early Christian community.
  • Reformation began in 1517 with Martin Luther's protests against the Catholic Church.
  • Followers of Luther became known as "Protestants."
  • Protestant ideas were seen as more aligned with the Bible.

2. The Pope

  • Catholic View:
    • Pope is the Vicar of Christ, infallible representative, and head of the global Catholic Church.
  • Protestant View:
    • No belief in human infallibility; only Jesus is the head of the Church.

3. The Eucharist

  • Catholic View:
    • Eucharist is central to worship; doctrine of transubstantiation (bread and wine become the body and blood of Christ).
  • Protestant View:
    • Known as Lord’s Supper or Communion; seen as a commemoration of Jesus’s death.
    • Some hold to consubstantiation, where body and blood coexist with bread and wine but remain separate.

4. Praying to Saints

  • Catholic View:
    • Intercessory prayer to saints who are considered holy; can pray through them.
  • Protestant View:
    • Direct access to God without intermediaries; no veneration of saints.

5. Authority of the Church

  • Catholic View:
    • Claims to be God's continuing voice; tradition and Scripture hold equal authority.
    • Quote: "It is not from Sacred Scripture alone..."
  • Protestant View:
    • Individuals interpret the Bible; less emphasis on traditions beyond Scripture.

6. Sacraments

  • Catholic View:
    • Seven sacraments: Baptism, Confirmation, Eucharist, Penance, Anointing of the Sick, Holy Orders, Matrimony.
  • Protestant View:
    • Typically two sacraments: Baptism and Eucharist (Lord’s Supper).

7. Salvation

  • Protestant View:
    • Salvation through faith in Jesus; declared righteous immediately upon faith.
  • Catholic View:
    • Salvation is a process dependent on grace received through church traditions.

8. Priesthood

  • Protestant View:
    • Horizontal priesthood; everyone is considered a priest (1 Peter 2:9).
  • Catholic View:
    • Ordained priests with authority to forgive and administer sacraments.

9. Tradition

  • Catholic View:
    • Tradition holds equal authority with Scripture.
    • Quote from the Catholic Catechism regarding tradition and Scripture.
  • Protestant View:
    • Scripture alone is authoritative; no other traditions.

10. View of Mary

  • Catholic View:
    • Mary is the mother of Jesus and the Church; believed to be conceived without original sin (Immaculate Conception) and assumed into heaven.
    • Continues to intercede for the Church.
  • Protestant View:
    • Mary is honored only as Jesus's earthly mother; believed to have sinned and awaits resurrection.

Conclusion

  • Recap of differences explored.
  • Encouragement for viewers to ask questions or suggest further topics.
  • Invitation to follow on social media for more content.