đŸ“‰

Iceland's Financial Crisis and Deregulation Lessons

Sep 13, 2024

Lecture Notes on the Financial Crisis and Deregulation

Overview of Iceland

  • Stable democracy with high standard of living
  • Low unemployment and government debt until 2000
  • Strong infrastructure: clean energy, food production, fisheries
  • Good healthcare, education, low crime
  • Nearly reached an "end-of-history" status

Deregulation Policies (2000 Onwards)

  • Initiated by Iceland’s government
  • Allowed multinational corporations to exploit natural resources (e.g., aluminum smelting plants)
  • Environmental and economic consequences of deregulation
  • Privatization of Iceland's three largest banks leading to financial deregulation experiment

Financial Deregulation Consequences

  • Banks borrowed $120 billion (10x Iceland's economy)
  • Rapid increase in stock and house prices, massive bubble
  • Major players emerged, e.g., Jan Asger Johannesson, who acquired assets with borrowed money
  • Banks advised clients to withdraw funds into money market accounts

Regulatory Failures and Collapsing Banks

  • Regulatory bodies failed to protect citizens
  • Conflicts of interest, with regulators becoming bank employees
  • US accounting firms and credit rating agencies failed to identify issues

Collapse of Iceland's Banks (2008)

  • Resulted in tripling unemployment in six months
  • Widespread loss of savings

Broader Context of Financial Crisis (2008)

  • Global financial crisis triggered by Lehman Brothers' bankruptcy
  • Resulted in recessions and massive job losses globally
  • Major financial institutions had made reckless investments and deregulation led to destructive practices

Historical Perspective on Financial Regulation

  • Financial regulations post-Great Depression led to 40 years of stability
  • 1980s deregulation allowed increased risk-taking and created conditions for future crises
    • Example: deregulation of savings and loan institutions leading to previous crisis
    • Key players: Donald Regan (Treasury Secretary), Alan Greenspan (Federal Reserve)
  • 1999 Graham-Leach-Bliley Act repealed Glass-Steagall Act, enabling riskier financial practices

Role of Rating Agencies and Financial Products

  • Rating agencies like Moody's and S&P played a significant role in the crisis
  • Creation of unregulated derivatives market (e.g., credit default swaps)
  • Increased speculative practices led to market vulnerabilities

Key Events Leading to 2008 Crisis

  • Rapid expansion of subprime lending and CDOs
  • Major financial firms betting against the very securities they sold to clients
  • Lack of meaningful oversight and accountability

Regulatory Responses Post-Crisis

  • Government bailout of major banks and financial institutions
  • Slow response from regulators and lack of criminal prosecutions for top executives
  • Aftermath: growing inequality, layoffs, and foreclosures

Conclusions and Takeaways

  • Financial institutions prioritized profit over ethical responsibility, leading to systemic failures
  • Need for regulatory reforms to prevent future crises
  • The importance of transparency and accountability in financial markets
  • Ongoing challenges with lobbying and political influence from the financial sector

Reflection on Current Financial Practices

  • Call for stronger regulations in executive compensation and lending practices
  • Recognition of the need for reform to protect consumers and ensure stability in the financial system