Balancing Technology and Education

Sep 7, 2024

Lecture on Education, Technology, and Teaching

Introduction

  • The speaker compares an apple to the American public education system.
  • Highlights a gap between appearance/perception and reality in education systems.
  • Discusses media's focus on teachers when addressing education performance issues.

Personal Background

  • Speaker was a former 6th and 7th-grade teacher in math and science.
  • Entered education journalism, moved to Silicon Valley.
  • Encountered narratives that technology would solve educational problems.

Technology in Education

  • Skeptical about technology solving all educational issues.
  • Shared experience from USC Hybrid High College Prep:
    • Charter school with students on devices 90% of the day.
    • 50% of students were credit deficient by end of freshman year.
  • LA Unified School District's iPad initiative:
    • Lack of teacher input and professional development.
    • Led to the resignation of the superintendent.

Importance of Teachers

  • Teachers ask the best questions and have strong relationships with students.
  • Shared a story about Ricardo Elizalde, an effective teacher using technology to build student confidence:
    • Used Macs and iMovie for student projects.
    • Students created digital shorts to demonstrate learning.

Positive Outcomes from Teacher Involvement

  • Hybrid High's turnaround with new leadership:
    • Focused on teacher involvement and less device dependency.
    • Provided teachers with budget for technology purchases.
    • Improved student outcomes: 100% graduation and college acceptance.

Local Context: Chicago

  • Mention of job cuts in Chicago Public Schools in 2016.
  • Simultaneous hiring of an executive director of personalized learning.
  • Concerns about technology-based learning environments lacking collaboration.

Conclusion

  • Advocates for a balance between technology and human interaction in education.
  • Emphasizes the importance of the triangular relationship: student, technology, teacher.
  • Leaves the audience with a question: How to balance technology utility and human nature in education?

Final Thoughts

  • Stresses the sacred relationship between teachers and students.
  • Encourages preserving this relationship while integrating technology.