Crash Course: Separation of Powers and Checks and Balances

Jul 24, 2024

Crash Course Government and Politics: Separation of Powers and Checks and Balances

Introduction

  • Lecturer: Craig
  • Topic: Fundamental concepts of American government - Separation of powers and checks and balances

Separation of Powers

  • Definition: Division of national government into three branches:
    1. Legislative Branch
    2. Executive Branch
    3. Judicial Branch
  • Legislative Branch:
    • Detailed in Article I of the Constitution
    • Longest and most detailed article
    • Main job: Make laws
    • Secondary job: Blame assignment during failures (humorous note)
  • Executive Branch:
    • Detailed in Article II Section I
    • States "The executive power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America."
    • Role: Execute laws, ensure government functions
    • President is like the CEO of the US
    • Power found in the Oath of Office
  • Judicial Branch:
    • Detailed in Article III
    • Shortest article (3 sections)
    • Role: Interpret laws
    • Includes Supreme Court and inferior courts as authorized by Congress

Checks and Balances

  • Definition: Each branch has the power to limit (check) the others, creating a balance between them
  • Legislative Checks:
    • Concern: Prevent tyrannical president (Reference: King George III)
    • Impeach and remove the President
    • Senate can reject Presidential appointments (advice and consent)
    • Investigate executive activities
    • Override Presidential veto with 2/3 vote
    • Refuse to pass laws or fund executive programs
    • Impeach and remove judges
    • Change court systems and jurisdiction
    • Pass laws overriding Supreme Court decisions (if not based on Constitution)
    • Propose Constitutional Amendments (e.g., 13th, 14th, 15th Amendments)
  • Executive Checks:
    • Veto Congressional laws
    • Call special sessions of Congress
    • Implement laws contrary to Congressional intentions (rare)
    • Vice President can break Senate ties
    • Nominate Supreme Court justices and federal judges
    • Pardon individuals convicted by courts
    • Refuse to carry out court decisions
  • Judicial Checks:
    • Declare laws unconstitutional
    • Chief Justice presides over impeachment trials
    • Declare executive actions unconstitutional
    • Issue warrants in federal crime cases

Rationale for Checks and Balances

  • Fear of a tyrannical central government harming citizens' rights
  • Separation and checks make harmful government actions more difficult
  • Explained in Federalist 51 by James Madison
    • "...necessary constitutional means and personal motives to resist encroachments of the others..."
    • Argued that government is a reflection of human nature, and safeguards are needed to control abuses

Conclusion

  • Madison's viewpoint: Human nature requires checks and balances in government
  • Checks and balances protect from potential abuses by leaders