Lecture on Grammar and Language Standards

Introduction

• Opening Questions: Discussion on who uses proper grammar and why.
• Common Attitudes: Grammar often seen as terrifying; errors considered morally wrong.

Personal Background

• Speakers: Elizabeth and David O’Brien.
• Education Experience: Limited and confusing grammar instruction in K-12 and college.
• Turning Point: Inspired by others to make grammar engaging.

Grammar's Place in Education

• Current Status: Fading out of schools; viewed as boring or unnecessary.
• Mission: To advocate for grammar instruction.
• Controversy: Discovering the controversial nature of grammar instruction.

Understanding Grammar

• Definitions:
  • Linguistic View: Grammar as the underlying structure of a language.
  • Popular View: Grammar as correct vs. incorrect speech.
  • Descriptive vs. Prescriptive: Descriptivism (linguists) vs. Prescriptivism (popular belief).
• Examples: Double negatives in English, French, and Italian.

The Language Wars

• Descriptivists vs. Prescriptivists: Ongoing debate about language standards.
• Prescriptive Rules: Often seen as outdated or inaccurate.
• Need for Standards: Balance between descriptive and prescriptive approaches suggested.

Importance of Grammar Instruction

• Empowerment: Grammar helps articulate thoughts clearly.
• Misconceptions: Often tied to self-esteem issues in education.
• Tools for Expression: Grammar can aid in self-expression by providing clear rules.

Historical Context

• Progressive Education: Shifted focus away from grammar.
• Traditional vs. Progressive: Debate on best approaches to teaching grammar.

Innovative Teaching Methods

• Diagramming Sentences: Visual method for teaching grammar.
• Modern Approaches: Digital tools and engaging methods to teach grammar.

The Role of Standards

• Cultural Impact: Standard English viewed as oppressive by some.
• Code-Switching: Importance of knowing different dialects and registers.
• Educational Challenges: Balancing respect for students' natural dialects with teaching standard English.

Conclusion

• Language as a Tool: Grammar as a means to enhance communication and understanding.
• Final Thoughts: Understanding language helps us understand ourselves.

---

Key Takeaways

• Grammar is both a structured system and a set of prescriptive rules.
• There is value in teaching grammar despite debates over its form and application.
• Different educational philosophies influence the teaching and perception of grammar.
• Understanding standard English is important for effective communication in broader society.
• There is a need to balance teaching standard language with respecting linguistic diversity.