Homework: How expert are expert stock pickers

Sep 24, 2024

Lecture: Smart Investing and Ignoring Expert Stock Pickers

Introduction

  • Investment advice can be overwhelming and noisy.
  • Smart investing doesn't require minute-by-minute stock tracking.
  • The series will provide rules for smart investing, focusing on long-term wealth growth.

Investment Rule #1: Ignore the Expert Stock Pickers

  • 1973 economist Burton Malkiel's claim: A blindfolded monkey throwing darts could pick stocks as well as experts.
  • John Stossel tested this by selecting stocks with darts and performed better than managed funds.
  • Random picking can do as well as professionals.

Mutual Funds Overview

  • Actively Managed Funds:
    • Professionals pick stocks.
    • Charge fees.
  • Passive Mutual Funds:
    • Invest in a broad index like S&P 500.

Performance of Mutual Funds

  • S&P 500 often outperforms actively managed mutual funds.
  • Most funds that beat the market one year don’t continue to do so in subsequent years.
  • Past Performance: Not a predictor of future success.
    • Study: Less than 4% of top-performing funds remain so after two years.

Analysis: Skill vs. Luck

  • Few funds consistently outperform the market; hard to separate skill from luck.
  • Example with coin flipping:
    • Over years, statistically, some will appear successful purely by chance.
  • Warren Buffett as a case study:
    • Known for smart investments but recent underperformance highlights the role of luck.

Conclusion

  • Avoid paying for high-cost professional money management.
  • Lesson: Ignore aggressive stock tips.
  • Upcoming topics include the Efficient Market Hypothesis.

Additional Resources

  • Practice questions to test investment knowledge.
  • Next video teaser: Investing lessons from a space shuttle disaster.

These notes provide a summary of the key points discussed in the lecture on smart investing and the importance of ignoring aggressive stock-picking advice.