India's Evolving Foreign Policy Landscape

Oct 7, 2024

Fourth Ramnath Goenka Lecture by Mr. Anand Goenka

Introduction

  • Delivered by Mr. Anand Goenka, addressing the spirit of Ramnath Goenka.
  • Reference to Albert Einstein's theory on political insanity and relevance in world politics.

Global Political Changes

  • Profound transformation in the international order.
  • Key examples: American nationalism, China's rise, Brexit, rebalancing of the global economy.
  • Return of old empires: Russia, Iran, Turkey.
  • Volatility in the Middle East and changes in Africa and South America.
  • Shifts in power definition: technology, connectivity, and trade.
  • Weakening of multilateralism and impact on climate change.

India's Changing Global Relationships

  • Increased relevance of relationships with the US and China.
  • Steady Russian relationship and rising importance of Japan.
  • Rediscovery of Europe, particularly France as a strategic partner.
  • Strengthened ties in the Gulf, ASEAN, and Australia.
  • Expansion of outreach to Africa and South America.
  • Unprecedented investment in India's neighborhood.

Strategic Adaptation and National Interest

  • Importance of recognizing change to exploit opportunities.
  • India's national strategy: expand space and options for prosperity, peace, and influence.
  • Need for an unsentimental audit of Indian foreign policy.
  • Hard-headed assessments of geopolitics lead to success.

Phases of Indian Foreign Policy

Phase 1: 1946-62

  • Era of optimistic non-alignment during a bipolar world.
  • Focus on resisting constraints and leading Asia and Africa.
  • Ended with the 1962 conflict with China.

Phase 2: 1962-71

  • Period of realism and recovery.
  • Made pragmatic security and political choices.
  • Dealt with external pressures on Kashmir.

Phase 3: 1971-1991

  • Greater Indian regional assertion.
  • Shift following the sino-us rapprochement.
  • Complications due to the US-China-Pakistan axis.

Phase 4: Post-1991

  • Unipolar world with a radical rethink.
  • Focus on strategic autonomy and economic openness.

Phase 5: Post-1998

  • India as a balancing power.
  • India-U.S. nuclear deal and cooperation with China on global issues.

Phase 6: Post-2014

  • China's growing momentum and new global realities.
  • Multipolarity and the need for a proactive diplomatic approach.

Lessons from Past Foreign Policy

  • Recognition of the need for realism and pragmatic assessments.
  • Economic strategy: leveraging global opportunities and dealing with trade challenges.
  • Engaging multiple players and ensuring strategic autonomy.
  • Risk-taking in diplomacy for greater influence.
  • Importance of reading global trends correctly.

Current Foreign Policy Direction

  • Energetic diplomacy recognizing world changes.
  • Focus on maritime geography and security challenges.
  • India's greater role in global conversations and humanitarian efforts.
  • Need for a multipolar Asia with India as a key player.
  • Avoiding dogma and focusing on pragmatic goals.

Conclusion

  • Emerging as a leading power requires putting dogmas behind.
  • Importance of fresh thinking and a new consensus at home for a changing world order.

The lecture reflects on India's foreign policy journey and strategic adjustments necessary to navigate the evolving global landscape.