Ethics and Future of Designer Babies

May 20, 2025

Lecture Notes: Designer Babies and Gene Therapy

Introduction

  • The concept of designer babies involves altering or selecting genetic traits.
  • Recent advancements in gene therapy make this a closer reality.
  • Ethical issues arise regarding trait selection and the extent of technology’s use.

Technologies Enabling Designer Babies

  1. Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD)

    • The simplest method, not involving gene editing.
    • Selects viable eggs based on desired traits (e.g., disease screening, gender determination).
  2. Transcription Activator-Like Effector Nucleases (TALENs)

    • Enzymes designed to edit specific parts of DNA.
    • Used in designing plants, fuels, and pets to specifications.
  3. Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats (CRISPR)

    • Discovered in bacteria; allows DNA modification.
    • Theoretically enables genome-wide editing.

Current Usage and Implications

  • PGD is currently used in human pregnancies (first case in 1988).
  • TALENs and CRISPR are not yet deemed safe for human embryos.
  • Gene screening options include gender, appearance, intelligence, disease, and personality.

Emerging Technologies

  • Three-person babies:
    • Involves mitochondrial DNA from a third person.
    • Prevents certain diseases (e.g., muscular dystrophy).

Future Possibilities

  • Genetic manipulation techniques may evolve to:
    • Design traits like eye color, hair color, disease resistance.
    • Enhance brain function, muscle mass, lifespan.
    • Develop new human abilities, akin to X-men.

Societal Impacts

  • Potential reduction in genetic and inherited diseases.
  • Increased lifespan and success rate in life.
  • Potential risks include:
    • Increased terminated embryos.
    • Damage to gene pool and loss of individuality.
    • Unpredictable consequences from gene editing.

Main Ethical Issues

  • Determination of good vs. bad traits.
  • Risk of eliminating uniqueness in society.
  • High costs leading to socioeconomic inequality.

Conclusion

  • Designer babies are becoming increasingly feasible.
  • While there are benefits, ethical and societal concerns loom large.
  • Over-control of nature poses potential risks to humanity.