Issues in UPSC Examinations and IAS Recruitment System

Jul 12, 2024

Issues in UPSC Examinations and IAS Recruitment System

Introduction

  • Concerns about the transparency and integrity of entrance exams, particularly NEET and UPSC.
  • Highlighting the case of Dr. Puja Khedkar and alleged systemic manipulation in IAS recruitment.

Case of Dr. Puja Khedkar

  • Initial Actions: Joined as a probationary officer in Pune, made unreasonable demands (e.g., VIP number plate, beacon light, personal staff, etc.) violating service rules.
  • Influence: Leveraged her father, a senior retired officer, to fulfill these demands, bypassing regulations.
  • Transfer: Complaints led to her transfer to Washim, raising questions about rule-bending in the transfer process.
  • PMO Involvement: The PMO has requested a report on her actions, and the Lal Bahadur Shastri National Academy of Administration is also investigating.
  • Further Incidents: Unauthorized entry into Maharashtra Chief Secretary’s cabin demonstrating misconduct.

Financial and Personal Assets

  • Assets: Holds 110 acres of agricultural land, multiple plots and flats, luxury cars, substantial gold, partnerships with private companies, and personal assets worth 17-20 crores.
  • Wealth Transparency: Discrepancies in declared wealth between personal assets and her father’s election affidavit.
  • Reservation Misuse: Suspected misuse of OBC and disability certificates to gain entry into IAS.
  • Medical Verification Evasion: Refusal to undergo mandatory medical tests at AIIMS Delhi multiple times, later submitted a disputed certificate from a private hospital.

Broader Implications

  • Systemic Issues: This case raises concerns about potential widespread manipulation within the IAS recruitment process.
  • Questions Raised: Possible issues of political and influential interference in UPSC exams, exploitation of reservation categories, and the integrity of the world’s most difficult exams.
  • Nepo Influence: Potential nepotism in IAS recruitment highlighted by Khedkar’s administrative family background.

Government Response Needed

  • Investigations: Must investigate the integrity of the reservation and disability certification processes in UPSC selections.
  • Transparency: Ensure no political or influential interference in IAS recruitment.
  • Training and Culture: Improve training and reduce entitlement culture among IAS officers.
  • Reformation: Systemic reforms in UPSC to maintain its credibility and fairness.
  • Action Points: Immediate steps to resolve doubts and prevent further erosion of trust in national examinations and recruitment processes.

Conclusion

  • The integrity of UPSC exams and the IAS recruitment process is crucial for public trust and effective administration.
  • Immediate and thorough investigations are necessary to address and rectify these serious concerns.