Overview
A fatal hit-and-run of cyclist Scott Habermell in Albuquerque on May 29, 2024, initially went unsolved until a video surfaced months later, revealing involvement of several minors in the crime. The investigation led to the identification and arrest of four youths, some of whom were charged with serious offenses including first-degree murder.
Incident Discovery and Initial Investigation
- Cyclist Scott Habermell was found severely injured and later died from blunt force trauma after a hit-and-run at 4:40 a.m.
- Initial evidence included a mangled bicycle, personal items, and limited grainy surveillance footage.
- The victim was identified as a 63-year-old physicist en route to work.
- The case was closed due to lack of leads until new evidence emerged months later.
Emergence of Video Evidence
- In February 2025, an anonymous tip led police to an Instagram video filmed from inside the stolen car during the incident.
- The video was posted by 11-year-old Messiah, detailing the crime and multiple prior offenses.
- Other evidence included videos depicting theft, firearms, and various crimes by Messiah and peers.
Identification and Apprehension of Suspects
- Messiah (11), William "Will" Garcia (15), and Jonathan "Johnny" Overbay (13) were identified as participants; Elijah "Eli" King (15) was later revealed as a fourth suspect.
- All were questioned or taken into custody; some invoked their right to silence, while others communicated with law enforcement and guardians.
- Investigators collected digital evidence, DNA, and fingerprints, and executed search warrants.
Legal Proceedings and Charges
- Jonathan Overbay pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and received the maximum juvenile sentence, to be held until age 21.
- William Garcia was transferred to adult court on first-degree murder and conspiracy charges.
- Elijah King was indicted for first-degree murder and conspiracy, pleading not guilty and held without bond.
- Messiah, initially housed by youth services, was later charged with murder, pending further details due to his age.
Investigative and Family Reactions
- Families and guardians were informed and often present during interrogations; most advised their children not to speak without legal counsel.
- Law enforcement coordinated follow-ups with victims’ families and emphasized their commitment to resolving the case.
Decisions
- Initiate arrests and execute warrants for all identified suspects based on the surfaced video and corroborating evidence.
- Transfer William Garcia’s case to adult court due to the severity of charges.
Action Items
- TBD – Investigators: Cross-check DNA and fingerprints from suspects with evidence from the stolen car.
- TBD – Prosecutors: Proceed with legal cases, including trial preparations for Elijah King and further proceedings regarding Messiah.
Key Dates / Deadlines
- May 29, 2024: Date of fatal hit-and-run.
- September 24, 2024: Case initially closed pending new leads.
- February 2025: Anonymous tip and video evidence surface.
- March 21, 2025: Fourth suspect, Elijah King, identified.
- June 11, 2025: Grand jury indictment for Elijah King.
Questions / Follow-Ups
- Clarification on Messiah's current legal status and outcome due to his age.
- Confirmation on whether additional charges may be filed or other individuals involved.