Debates and Developments in Early American Government

Sep 26, 2024

Lecture on the First Republic: Week Six, Video Lecture One

Revolutionary War and New Government Debates

  • Revolutionary War sparked debates on replacing British monarchy.
  • Colonies experimented with self-government, creating a pool of ideas for a new government.

State Constitutions and Separation of Powers

  • State constitutions shared separation of powers to prevent abuse.
    • Executive: Governor
    • Legislature: State Legislature
    • Judicial: State Courts
  • Inclusion of Bill of Rights in constitutions to protect citizens' cherished rights.

Confederation and the Articles of Confederation

  • Richard Henry Lee's resolution led to the idea of a confederation among states.
  • Articles of Confederation adopted in November 1777, creating a weak national government.
  • Articles significant for the revolutionary fighters, not for modern government.

Virginia Statute of Religious Freedom

  • Written by Thomas Jefferson in 1786.
  • Declared no compulsion toward religion and no discrimination based on beliefs.
  • Basis for religious freedom in the First Amendment and Bill of Rights.

Equality and Suffrage Post-War

  • Spirit of independence led to a desire for equality, but no state had universal suffrage.
  • Voting rights tied to property ownership; land grants to veterans increased suffrage.
  • Grant of 1.5 million acres in 1787 settled debts and populated western lands.

New States and Land Ordinances

  • Western lands treated as equals to original states.
  • Land ordinances created in 1785 to pattern and manage land, excluding slavery in the Northwest.
  • Mason-Dixon line divided slavery regions, affecting pre-Civil War America.

Post-War Trade and Economic Challenges

  • States expanded trade globally but struggled with currency issues.
  • Articles of Confederation criticized for economic weakness, not military.

Calls for a Stronger Government

  • Wealthy businesspersons in need of a stronger government for currency regulation.
  • Debt payment issues threatened citizens' property and voting rights.

Shays' Rebellion

  • Farmers struggled with debts post-war, leading to Shays' Rebellion in Massachusetts.
  • Rebellion led by Daniel Shays; tactics reminiscent of Revolutionary War protest.
  • Exaggerated threats led to calls for stronger central government.

Revising the Articles of Confederation

  • Initial goal was to revise the Articles, but discussions led to the idea of a new republic.
  • Constitutional Convention of 1787 held in secrecy to draft a new Constitution.

Constitutional Convention and Key Figures

  • 39 men signed the new Constitution; average age 42, many were war veterans.
  • George Washington elected as president of the Convention.
  • James Madison's Virginia Plan proposed a new national government.

Slavery and Representation Issues

  • South Carolina and Georgia demanded protection of slavery.
  • Three-fifths Compromise reached for slave representation.
  • Slavery not mentioned explicitly; referred to as "property" in the Constitution.

Federal Government Structure and Concerns

  • Concerns about state size affecting representation and power.
  • Creation of a weak presidency to avoid tyranny; war declarations reserved for Congress.
  • Impeachment as a safeguard against presidential corruption.

Conclusion

  • Discussion on the new Constitution and its reception to be continued in the next lecture.