Chapter 3 Medical,Ethical and Legal Issues in Emergency Care

Nov 9, 2024

Chapter 3: Medical, Legal, and Ethical Issues

Core Principle

  • A basic medical, legal, and ethical principle of emergency cares to do no further harm.

Consent in Emergency Care

  • Consent is required from every conscious adult before care can be started.
  • Decision-making capacity is the ability of a patient to understand the information you are providing.
  • Patient Autonomy is the ride of a patient to make the scissors concerning his or her health.

Decision making

-The following factors should be considered when determining a patient’s decision-making capacity.

-Is the patient of legal age? Is the patient impaired by alcohol or drug intoxication or serious injury or illness? Does the patient appear to be experiencing significant pain? Does the patient have a significant injury that could distract him from my more serious injury? Are there any apparent hearing or visual problems? Is a language barrier present?

Types of Consent

  • Express Consent: Patient acknowledges and agrees to treatment. The consent must be informed consent, which means that you explained the treatment being offer along with the risk and benefits.

  • Implied Consent: Applies when a patient is unconscious or incapable of making decisions. (Intoxicated by drugs or alcohol.)

  • Involuntary Consent: For patients with mental illness or developmental delays; may involve guardians or legal authority.

  • Minors and Consent: Typically requires parental consent unless the minor is emancipated.

  • Emancipated minors are people who despite being under the legal age in a given state, can legally be treated as adults based on certain circumstances. (Ex. Married, members of the armed services, or if they are parents.)

-In every state when a parent cannot be reached to provide consent, healthcare providers are allowed to give emergency care to a child.

  • Loco Parentis, means in the position or place of a parent and can legally give consent for treatment of the minor if a parent guardian is not available for example teachers and school officials.

Decision-Making Capacity

  • Patient should understand information and make informed decisions.

  • Factors affecting capacity: age, impairment, pain, injury, language barriers.

Right to Refuse Treatment

  • Patients may refuse treatment if they have decision-making capacity.

  • Document refusals and involve medical control. -Make sure the patient understands everything that you say about the possible consequences of refusing treatment and document everything in your patient care report (PCR).

-If patient appears confused, and you cannot assume the decision to refuse is an informed refusal, providing treatment is usually a much more defensible position than failing to treat a patient! Things like contacting medical direction when you are unsure, and the use of law enforcement are good ways to ensure your own safety.

-Try to encourage the patient at least three times to allow treatment.

-It is essential for you to ask the patient to sign a refusal treatment form and document refusals.

  • Signatures should be witnessed by a family member or police officer to help you from a later claim.

Confidentiality and HIPAA

  • HIPAA regulates the protection of patient information.

  • PHI (Protected Health Information)

  • Breaches of confidentiality can lead to legal action. -Confidential information includes a patient history, assessment, findings, and treatment provided… disclosure of this information without proper authorization, may result in liability for breach of confidentiality.

Advanced Directives

  • DNR (Do not resuscitate order) Orders: Written document by physician, giving permission to medical personnel, not to attempt resuscitation in the event of cardiac arrest.

  • Even with DNR you are still obligated to provide supportive treatments, like oxygen, pain, relief, and comfort to a patient who is not in cardiac arrest.

Advance Directive can also be referred to as a Health Care Directive.

  • Advanced directive is a written document that allows for medical treatment to a patient if he or she becomes unable to make decisions.

  • Living Wills/Health Care Directives: Specify treatment preferences.

  • POLST/MOLST Forms: Physician Orders for Life Sustaining Treatment and Medical Orders for Life Sustaining Treatment forms describe acceptable interventions for terminally ill patients. Must be signed by a physician, physician, assistant, or nurse practitioner to be valid.

  • Durable Power of Attorney: is when patients have a named individual that makes decisions for them regarding their healthcare in the event that they are unable to make such decisions for themselves.

Determining Death

  • Death is the absence of circulatory and respiratory function.
  • Signs include absence of vital signs and definitive signs like rigor mortis.
  • Medical examiners involved based on the nature and scene of death. -Physician responsibility to determine the cause of death.
  • Hypothermia is a cooling of the body in which the internal body temperature becomes abnormally low.

Presumptive signs of death

-Unresponsive to painful stimuli, lack of carotid pulse or heartbeat, absence of chest rise and fall, no deep tendon or corneal reflexes, absence of pupillary reactivity, no systolic blood pressure, profound cyanosis, lowered or decreased body pressure.

Definitive signs of death

-obvious damage such as decapitation, dependent lividity, which is blood, settling to the lowest point of the body, causing discoloration of the skin, rigor mortis which is the stiffening of body muscles, algor mortis when the cooling of the body matches the ambient temperature, and putrefaction which is decomposition of body tissues typically occurs sometime between 40 and 96 hours after death.

Special Situations

  • Organ Donors: Indicated by a card or driver's license.
  • Medical ID Insignia: Contains critical information for treatment.

Scope of Practice

  • Defined by state law and further detailed by medical directors it outlines the care you are legally able to provide for your patient.

  • Actions outside the scope can be considered negligence.

Standards of Care

  • Standards can be imposed by law, local customs, and professional organizations.

-Standard of care is how a person with similar training and experience would act under similar circumstances.

Legal Concepts

Duty to Act

  • An individuals responsibility to provide patient care.

Negligence

  • Failure to provide standard care; requires duty, breach, damages, and causation.

Abandonment

  • Termination of care without proper transfer to another medical professional.

Assault & Battery

  • Assault: Threat of harm without consent.
  • Battery: Unlawful touching without consent.

Defamation

  • False statements damaging reputation; written (libel) or spoken (slander).

Good Samaritan Laws

  • Protects individuals who provide care in good faith without gross negligence.

Documentation

  • Accurate records are crucial for legal protection.
  • Part of the patient's permanent hospital record.

Ethical Responsibilities

  • EMTs must adhere to ethical standards and evaluate ethical dilemmas.

Legal Proceedings

  • EMTs can be involved in court as witnesses or defendants.
  • Important defenses include statute of limitations and governmental immunity.

Review Questions Summary

  • Express consent example: Patient extending arm for blood pressure.
  • Abandonment occurs without patient's consent.
  • False imprisonment involves unauthorized confinement.
  • Negligence is failing to provide standard care.
  • Implied consent applies when unable to reach a minor's guardians.
  • Advanced directives specify care if decision-making is lost.
  • Competent patients may legally refuse care.
  • Threatening restraint without consent constitutes assault.
  • Duty to act is present once on duty and dispatched.
  • Patient care reports are part of hospital records.

This concludes Chapter 3 with a focus on consent, legal duties, and ethical responsibilities in emergency medical care.