Exploring Different Types of Democracy

Aug 27, 2024

Types of Democracy

Introduction

  • Democracy: Rule by the people.
  • US Constitution: Establishes the US as a republic, not a direct democracy.
  • Direct Democracy: People vote directly on policies. Exists at state level, not federal.
    • Initiatives: Citizens propose bills/amendments for voting.
    • Referenda: Government writes bills for public approval.

Representative Democracy

  • Citizens vote for representatives who make policies.
  • Framers didn't trust public to wield power directly.
  • Republic vs Democracy: Framers established a republic; feared mob rule.

Three Types of Democracy

1. Participatory Democracy

  • Emphasizes broad participation by citizens in politics and civil society.
  • Citizens actively involved, influencing policy-making.
  • Examples:
    • Social Movements: Black Lives Matter, March for Our Lives, Tea Party, Occupy Wall Street.
  • Brutus No. 1: Supports participatory democracy.

2. Pluralist Democracy

  • Emphasizes group-based policy-making.
  • Groups/political parties of like-minded people promote policy agendas.
  • Federalist No. 10: Associated with pluralist democracy.
  • Participatory vs Pluralist: Sometimes blurry; focus on whether individual actions or group efforts are emphasized.

3. Elite Democracy

  • Emphasizes limited role for the people; elites hold disproportionate power.
  • Distrusts public; filters between people and policy-making needed.

Constitution and Democracy Types

  • Elite Democracy: Embodied by republican government and Electoral College.
  • Participatory Democracy: Supported by First Amendment freedoms and suffrage-expanding amendments (15th, 19th, 26th).
  • Pluralist Democracy: Supported by freedom of assembly allowing interest groups and political parties.

Conclusion

  • Constitution promotes all three types: participatory, pluralist, and elite democracy.

  • Note: For more resources, check out the ultimate review packet for study guides and practice tests.