📝

Understanding JK Rowling's Transphobic Rhetoric

Sep 14, 2024

Lecture Notes: Timeline of JK Rowling's Transphobia

Introduction

  • Topic: Breakdown of JK Rowling's transphobia over the years
  • Objective: Provide evidence to understand and explain her transphobic rhetoric
  • Importance: Highlight the harm caused by transphobic views and rhetoric

The Harm of Transphobia

  • Transphobia causes genuine harm to individuals and communities
  • Examples of harm:
    • International LGBT Plus Review linking Rowling to transphobic damage in the UK
    • A senator citing Rowling's essay to block LGBTQ+ protective legislation
    • UK Prime Minister's policy changes influenced by Rowling's rhetoric

Evolution of Rowling's Transphobia

  • 2017: Liked a tweet critical of trans women (claimed as accidental)
  • 2018: Repeated similar incidents
  • 2019: Open support for anti-trans views
  • 2020:
    • June: Tweet mocking gender-neutral language
    • Released transphobic essay "TERF Wars"
    • July: Liked tweet comparing hormone therapy to antidepressants
    • September: Published book with anti-trans themes

Prominent Reactions

  • Cast members of Harry Potter spoke against Rowling's views:
    • Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, Rupert Grint, Eddie Redmayne, and Bonnie Wright all expressed support for trans rights

2021-2023: Continued Transphobic Actions

  • 2021: Mocked Scottish police for recognizing trans identities
  • 2022:
    • March: Transphobic tweets on International Women's Day
    • Supported anti-trans film by Matt Walsh
    • Backed protests against Scottish Gender Recognition Act reform
    • Opened a women’s shelter explicitly excluding trans women
  • 2023:
    • Compared trans rights movement to Death Eaters from her books
    • Explicitly denied trans women’s identities in tweets
    • Donated ÂŁ70,000 to a legal battle against trans-inclusive definitions of "woman"

Recent Developments (2024)

  • March: Made transphobic comments towards a transgender journalist
  • Mother's Day 2024: Tweeted a transphobic joke

Conclusion

  • JK Rowling's transphobia has intensified over the years
  • Her influence amplifies transphobic rhetoric
  • Transphobia remains a minority but loud view
  • Continued support from trans allies and community leaders against her views

Resources

  • For further understanding, recommended videos and articles are available