Maruti Swift vs. Maruti Baleno: A Comparative Analysis

Introduction

• Focus: Comparing Maruti Swift and Maruti Baleno to address the question of why not buy Baleno if Swift is priced high.
• Swift Price Range: ₹6.5 lakh to ₹9.5 lakh.
• Cars Compared: Swift's top spec vs. Baleno Zeta trim (second from top but well-equipped).

External Design

• Swift: Sporty look.
• Baleno: More premium appearance.
• Dimensions and Features:
  • Baleno: Larger in length, width, and wheelbase; 16-inch wheels.
  • Swift: Shorter height; 15-inch wheels.
  • Both: LED headlamps.

Interior Comparison

Swift Interior

• Shared Components: Part sharing with Baleno (power window switches, HVAC).
• Cabin Feel:
  • All black with silver garnishes.
  • Sporty steering, good seat comfort.
• Equipment: Wireless charging, USB-A port, 9-inch touchscreen with Apple Carplay, Android Auto, and Alexa connectivity.
• Back Seat:
  • Limited knee and legroom due to shorter wheelbase.
  • Adequate headroom.
  • Rear AC vents, Type-C and USB-A ports.
  • Best for 2; snug fit for 3; Baleno better for 5.

Baleno Interior

• Overall Feel: Premium and spacious.
• Dashboard Design:
  • Layered with dark blue and silver panels.
  • Instrument cluster with silver rings.
• Storage: Larger glove box, driver armrest, better central console space.
• Seats: Soft, similar to Swift.
• Equipment (Zeta Trim): 7-inch touchscreen, reversing camera, rear AC vents, Type-C and USB-A ports.
  • Alpha Trim: Larger screen, 360° camera, heads-up display.
• Back Seat:
  • Better knee and headroom.
  • Easier to seat 3 people comfortably.
• Boot Space: 318 L (Baleno) vs. 265 L (Swift).

Driving Dynamics

Swift Engine & Performance

• Engine: New Z2E, 3-cylinder, 1.2 L, 82 HP.
• City Driving: Good low-end response.
• Refinement: Not as good as older car, noisy past 3000 RPM.
• Transmission: 5-speed AMT, smooth but noticeable lag.
• Ride Quality: Balanced comfort, low speed bumps can unsettle.
• Handling: Light steering, retains fun-to-drive aspect but loses out in engine appeal.

Baleno Engine & Performance

• Engine: 1.2 L K12 N, 4-cylinder, better refinement and performance (8 HP more).
• Driving Experience: Free-revving, better response past 2000 RPM.
• Performance Metrics: Faster acceleration (0-100, 20-80, 40-100 kph better than Swift).
• Transmission: Similar 5-speed AMT as Swift, with slight head nods at low speed.
• Ride Comfort: Softer, better at handling bumps.
• Handling: Swift is sharper, Baleno more comfortable.

Conclusion

• Price and Value:
  • Price Difference: Top spec Swift vs. Baleno differs by ₹39,000.
  • Features: Baleno offers more features (larger screen, 360° camera, wireless charger, HUD).
  • Overall Verdict: Baleno provides better space, performance, and a premium experience, making it a better choice and worth the price difference.