Transcript for:
Critical Examination of Islamic Beliefs

I believe that you two are morally better than Muhammad is. All right, so now we can have a simple conversation right now. So what's your question, bro? My question is, what is it that you guys are trying to do here? What's the point of this? The point of this? Okay, yeah. So the point of this is to... Yeah, I got you. The point of this is to show Muslims the truth. We believe that the group of Muslims that's here, that do the dawah here, they purposely lie to the Christians up here, the Muslims up here, feed them false information. And so we're... We're here to give the accurate information and also hopefully open people's minds to start thinking more and ultimately come to Christ, the true Christ. Because the Christ of the Quran is a terrible copy. It's a counterfeit. And so if you have a false Christ, you have a false gospel and a gospel that can't save you, a message that can't save. So for people who believe that Muhammad is a prophet, we emphatically deny that, but for a reason. Not because we hate Muslims, not because we hate the Quran. But because when we read the Quran and we read the hadith He is clearly one of the most obvious false prophets in history next to Joseph Smith What's that? So prophet Muhammad is that what is a fake when you're saying absolutely without without a doubt And I heard that Muslims are like being are you Muslim? Yeah. You're Muslim? Good. And you're Muslim too, right? Okay. So what's your question? How can we know more than, I guess, the millions of Muslims? Here's what we think. We think that the Muslims don't even know their own religion. I think that a lot of Muslims have this idea of Islam. As a matter of fact, I think that the Muslims that join Islam have a better character and have a better personality than even Muhammad did, a moral character. I believe that you two are morally- better than Muhammad is and I can demonstrate that to you guys if we have a real conversation no insults or nothing just a conversation of my observations and his observations and we go step by step I think we can prove that you guys are more moral than Muhammad so like for example so for example here's one of the top biggest ones would you guys sleep with a child no you would not would you Tell me no. Okay. Muhammad slept with a nine-year-old girl, Aisha, his wife, his child, right? You guys heard of Aisha? They'll tell you the same thing over there. Nothing we're ever saying is lying, right? So you guys know it? And just so that we, you know, because we have viewers here too. Can we read the hadiths to make sure that we're not lying? What are you guys showing us? They're like exactly what it seems like. Because it's straight from the Islamic sources. So, for example, you got that. So they don't want the pamphlets. I'm going to show you from a Muslim site. It's called Surah Al-Bukhari. Suna.com, you guys can look it up in any, I can send it to you. No, you can have it. It's a, yeah, so. That's a source out there. Yeah, so we have the sources here, but I want to give it to you guys straight from, so not on a pamphlet, but straight from the website itself that collects the hadiths, right? So this is from, let's see which one I want to read. So this is Suna Ibn Majah. I don't know if you guys, can you guys see it? Grade Sahih. The greatest Sahih. Right here. You see the grade? Grade Sahih. authentic most highest authentic right it says Abdullah said the Prophet married Aisha when she was seven years old and consummated the marriage with her when she was nine years old and he passed away when she was 18 so he had sex with her he made the marriage finalized by having sex with her at nine years old yeah yeah go ahead if you want to yeah yeah I got I got multiple of them I got six or different details, six or seven. And the early Muslim scholars like Ibn Kathir and people like that, they all say that there's no disagreement among the early scholars, among the early Muslims about Aisha's age. It's only nowadays that Muslims try to hide that or combat that, which is why we're here. Because they won't tell you this, but we will. Muslims? Muslims, they don't tell you this. When you, were you born in a Muslim family? Yeah. And you were too? Y'all never heard of his marriage? marriage with Aisha? I did. You did hear about it. So did you know she was a child? I don't know the numbers. It's confusing. Everybody says different numbers. There is not a single source that ever says that she's above the age of nine when he slept with her. Not a single Hadith. Nothing authentic. Nothing even Daif. Nothing weak. All it is is speculation from nowadays scholars trying to fix this problem because they know it's a problem. But how do you know, how do you believe that they're just making this up for today's people? And so because of this, because it's in their sources, we're quoting their sources and showing it to the Muslims. And they're lying about it. Who does not believe this? Okay, keep going. You guys ever heard that there's a war? more than one Quran? Has anybody told you you have more than one Quran? No. No, no, let's keep this going. So we have so many Quran. Tell them about this. Yeah. So this is a very important for childhood. They never say that the Quran has been changed or Quran has more than one Quran. Well, it has never been changed. In my life, I've written over like, I've used over 100 times, 100 Quran. They're all the Hafs. And they're always the same. Because they're all the Hafs. They're all the Hafs recitation. But the one that's so like the red one that he showed the brother, the one that he He agreed with? They might be there, right? They might be house or bush. They're probably reading or bush. No way. Really? Yeah. Where are you guys from? Where are you from? Somalia. Listen, let me check. It's Hobbs, I think. Did I see this too? Yeah, yeah. Well, me personally, the one I have at my house is this one. Oh, so you have the bush. Wow. Okay, so excuse me, the camera right there. It's okay. No, you can, we can make room. It just depends on me looking at it, like when I'm reading, because I don't speak Arabic yet. still so first what i'm doing right now is i i like learned how to read and write this yeah but i started with like learning to write it first yep yep and now i i learned it to read it and memorize it right now i'm almost about to be done with it but like that's like then then i'm gonna go go back and restart it again and then learn it as i go on yeah i feel like so then i feel like you should not like you should be able to like first learn it and then then like have questions about it because like you're asking like specific like parts that you're like okay define find this for me or it's not it's but but it's stuff we've studied i'm like i'm not going in here showing you some random word that i don't know about it's it's stuff like you don't have to i don't have to know spanish in order to uh you know um do a word study on what the word dios means i know it means god or whatever right and then i could study how that came about yada yada so what what we're doing is we do word studies from islamic scholars what they say about it what the umma say about it what the sahaba said about it and then we see what they said and we come with that information It's not from us. So when, for example, when Al-Tabari says that, you know, one reading makes more sense than the other reading, that the other reading cannot possibly fit, then that's a scholar saying that there's a textual difference. Those are two different Qurans there. It's as simple as that. There's a textual variant there. And so when we can say, oh, well, we prefer this one. As soon as you say, we choose one over another, you're admitting that there's two different Qurans. You're admitting that there's a difference. Have you seen anyone that comes up to you and says, oh, I don't believe this one. Yes. Oh, yes. Check out Bible or Quran on his videos. He shows them these Qurans. What they say. Yes. But they never give. I have a people, Arabic people, they came, I give them this one, right over when I told them to read that, no, no, this is a fake one, this is somebody printed on there. And you know, Allah promised that, Allah promised that he's going to protect that, okay? He's going to preserve that. Where is Allah now? Has so many different Qur'ans, there's 30 to 40 different Qur'ans. And there is so many, I mean, where is Allah now? He says he's going to preserve that, he's going to protect that. Where is Allah? He's not protecting. What do you mean he's not protecting? Because Qur'an say that... This is I bring it and I'm going to protect those things. Well, that's what the Day of Judgment is for. Right now on this planet, you're here on your own will. But then everything that you do is being written down. So that's what the Day of Judgment is for? You say you stand in front of Jesus on the Day of Judgment. Is that so? Yes. So then you're saying Jesus is going to come and judge on the Day of Judgment? Yes. Well, okay. So then if we're believing a lot, then we're going to stand in front of Jesus. the day of judgment is when we come and we're judged and we're shown the book of all the good deeds and the bad deeds we've done. That is when you get punished for any bad deeds that you have done. No, no, but I'll let you ask it. Allah is not going to struck you down right now because you step, you can go ahead and step on the Qutb if you want to. He's not going to struck you down right now. He did it to the Jews. What? He did it to the Jews, chapter 4, verse 47. And he said that because they disobeyed him, he struck them down, turned them faces into monkeys and pigs and stuff. So that's how Allah operates. It's funny. You're about to laugh. It's chapter 4, man. Chapter 4. So, that promise is not for the, you know, judgment day. That promise is for the judgment day. He said he's gonna save in this world the book. I have seen religions go ahead and step down on the kitab. No people they are. Like I said, but first of all, what you were telling earlier, don't keep it like that. Why is that? Where is it that you're not supposed to do it? No, because like I was told that... This is my Bible. See the Holy Bible, this is the Holy Bible, I keep it that way, there's nothing wrong with that. Do you think there's nothing wrong with that? When I was being taught the Quran, I was told... That's exactly what you thought, that's wrong. No, no, I was told that this is the worst... This is the worst from God. This is the worst of Allah. So you as a human, this is the worst of Allah. So you as a human are supposed to respect it. If you believed it, Samiraat, no one's going to stop me. But me, I won't do that. This is like the worst of Allah that I should respect it. But see what happened in the Bible, it does not say that if you drop it or if you do that, it's going to be punished for you. Why are you saying that it will be, if you do something disrespectfully, it will be going back? No, no, no. I mean, potentially if you do that, there's some consequences, right? No, that's not, Allah doesn't exist. Allah doesn't exist. Allah does not exist. Allah doesn't exist. Yeah, Allah does not exist. No. If I go and throw this, if I go and throw this, what do you say, kitab across the street right now, nothing is going to happen to me. I agree. But Allah at the Day of Judgment will ask me, why did you do that to my words? I don't think so. Because His words are supposed to be in you. Not like a physical book is just a physical book. Right? But His words are supposed to be in your heart. So like, the Bible says that when the Messiah comes, Jesus Christ, that God will give us a new law and it's not going to be like... like the old law that's written down but he's going to put his law in our hearts that's what that's what our god says so it having it in a book and this can be destroyed this can be burnt on fire god doesn't hold that again he holds how you how you conduct yourself with the law that he put in your heart you know what i'm saying what's that what's the law what's the law he put in your heart the law oh oh it's the gospel message that that um he has given you a more not yet you By accepting the Messiah, accepting Jesus Christ. He will put it in you. And as you walk day in, day out, you'll see how it's implemented in your life. And it will wake you the heck up, bro. It'll wake you up, I promise you. So the law is, so Jesus said, this is what I command you to do. To love as you love, to love your enemies and your neighbors as you love yourself. Do good unto others. And that you love each other. how you love each other they will know that you're from me and you have to do my command do everything i commanded you to do so you have to believe that he's the son the eternal divine son of god these are the laws these are the commandments that god and that the messiah has put in us so he's inviting you okay so so if you become christian you have god law in your heart absolutely so why does christian still kill like other christians other there's no christians killing other christians if they're doing that they're not christians only Christians by name. Like for example, you said if they believe in God, like, no, not, not, not a hypocritical belief. Not, not a hypocritical. Yeah. Not a hypocritical belief. Like for example, if you, do you believe that, uh, um, ISIS are real Muslims? Right. But they claim to be real Muslims. They claim to follow the Quran. They quote certain scriptures. They believe with their mouth, right? Exactly. And so what we're saying, that's my response is that people can claim to be Christian all day, but if their actions show that their faith is invalid, they're not really. really Christians. They're fake. They're hypocrites. That's what Jesus says, that those who do wickedness, even though they call me Lord, those are the ones who actually practice wickedness and lawlessness. I never knew you. He was never with me. So that's the type of mentality that Christ gives us as opposed to this ritualistic, you know, way of how Allah brings it. You have to do a certain thing at a certain time and pray a certain amount of times and wash a certain way in order for your prayer. to be accepted or for your do-out to be accepted. He doesn't say that though. That's in your Hadith. Yeah, but that's actually better than the Christian way. No, really. This is the same though. Usually Christians have like most Christians have a lot of different understanding of God and a lot of different ways to pray. No, Christians all believe in the same one God who is triune, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. I've seen... So, look. There will be little things that we have different opinions on. I tell you, you probably pray the same way. So who... How do I know? And differently. And differently. But that's the freedom that God gives us in Christianity. He says, talk to your father how you will. He knows what you need. Just talk to him. So what he'll be praying for. We pray in a certain way, but we... God understands. You have to recite the Quran when you pray, right? You have to do something for God, though. Do you see that? You have to do something for God in order for him to hear you. That's... God... God... came to us because we couldn't make it to him. That's the Christian message. Nothing you do is good enough. You cannot earn God's mercy or forgiveness or buy his ear. If you do what he tells you, you probably do it. And how well do you do what God tells you? Huh? How well do you do what God tells you? You do the actions. How well do you do the actions? Well, if you do the actions and you succeed, you're good. Everyone messes up. Exactly. So what happens when you mess up? Allah doesn't say, Allah says, if you mess up, that's it. You're done. He doesn't see that. What does he say? The reason of praying is so that you pray, and then you ask for forgiveness from the sins that you've done in the past. Do you know that you're forgiven? No, no one knows. Exactly. You don't know that you're forgiven for your sins? No, you do not. Let me show you. How are you going to know? Don't go back to that. Do you go home and say, Oh, according to the Bible, I've been forgiven. I know that I have. Absolutely. Let me show you. But that's your belief. I can also go pray tonight a hundred times and be like, Oh, I'm forgiven. I can go ahead and leave. I do. I don't know if I'm forgiven or not because no, Allah doesn't speak to you. Because Allah doesn't promise you forgiveness. Jesus does. Jesus promises us forgiveness. I can show you guys this. Notice how our God promises us forgiveness while your God leaves you in the loop. And so basically on Judgment Day, you're like, hopefully, hopefully he got me. Hopefully I make it in. You know what I'm saying? Hopefully I've done enough to where God is happy enough to let me into Jinnah. But this is what Jesus says. Well, you know, when you do good. You know, you're not, and you still don't know, you still don't know you might not go, but you know you did the right thing, right? But what about your bad thing, your bad things? See, your good stuff won't outweigh the bad or vice versa. This is what the Bible says. The Bible says that our good works is filthy rags to God. Why? Because he's holy. He's holy and he's just, he's perfect. The Bible. Let me just say, what did he say? He says that our filthy, our good works are as filthy rags to God. In God's eyes are good works. He's like so what where's your heart? Where's your faith? Yes, the Bible says that because there's nothing we can do to earn God's mercy to earn his forgiveness No, you believe that you have to do these good works in order to earn Okay, so like for example Do you have salvation as a Muslim right now? You believe Muhammad is a prophet you believe he's a seller the messengers you believe Allah is the only true God Do you have salvation? Wait, what's the Salvation? Are you going to heaven? If I believe the thing? Yes. And I do what God tells me to do? Right now, if you were to die today, would you go to heaven? I don't know that. Exactly. That's only up to Allah. I do not know. And Allah never promised you that, right? Huh? Allah never promised you that, right? Everything that I follow is everything that Allah said in the Quran. Right. So let me show you... Everything that God tells me to do, I know I am going to. So let me show you what Jesus said. I'm going to show you the difference. Because Muhammad said, I don't know what will happen to you or with me. That's what Muhammad said in the Quran. I don't know what Allah is going to do with you. Abu Bakr, he used to cry before he died because he was afraid that Allah will send him to hell. Even though he believed in Muhammad. Even though Muhammad... If we're humans, we might mess up any time. You're right. Exactly. It means that you don't know. You don't have this promise. Yeah, I don't know the future. Because there's nothing you can do. If I've been doing really good... What's really good? I like everything that Islam tells me. if I do that. What does that matter? And I know today I'm ensured that I'm actually doing the good. It matters not. I don't know tomorrow, so that's why I'm worried. Let me show you why you shouldn't be worried if you come to Christ. This is what Jesus promises us. He says in John chapter 14, He says, Let not your hearts be troubled. Don't worry. Don't worry about it. I wish Abu Bakr would have heard these words. Don't worry about it. He says, Believe in God. Believe also in me. He says, And In my father's house are many rooms in heaven. There's many rooms in heaven, right? He says, if it were not so, would I have told you that I go to prepare the place for you? So he says, and if I go and prepare the place for you, which he did, I will come again and I will. Not I might, not I may. I will take you to myself. So he gives us the promise when we believe in him truthfully. Truthfully. Truthfully in your heart. With. With your heart, not just some fake, you know, with my mouth, I just say, oh yeah, Jesus, I believe in you, yada, yada. No. In your heart, it's a heart change. You turn from your sins. You put your trust in the Messiah. That's what he's saying. You believe that, he will bring you and take you to him. Can we stop? Sure. Let's say right now, you do believe in whatever that, right? I believe in it, yes. If you hate me enough. Hate you? Yeah, if you just, let's say, for example, just like. If I hate you, I'm a hypocrite. Yeah. So what does that mean? If I hate you, if I hate you, then I don't have God. Because the Bible literally says the person who does not love his brother does not have God, does not have Christ. You don't, that's not true faith. But today you have the capacity to kill me if you are out there. I have the ability to, but I'm not going to. You need me enough if I've done something like that. I would never hate you. I can't. Christ compels me to love you, even if you were to curse us out. Why not? What if I attack you? And you kill me? What about that? Well, I mean, if you threaten my life, I'm going to defend myself. You die in the process, that's it. No, I'm not murdering you. I didn't set out like, ooh, I'm going to kill this dude. You know what I'm saying? That's not murder. That's self-defense. So the belief is, if you're just good enough, you'll get to there. You'll get to heaven. Not here. The Bible says you're not good enough. So Romans chapter 3, it says, all men, everybody, has fallen short of the glory of God. We all fell short. We all messed up. So do you believe that, me personally right now, if I'm not following the Bible, I will not enter? If you're not following Christ. You do not have the kingdom of God. I'm still confused. You say a father and you say Christ. Me personally, we'll go to hell. Yes, without Christ. Because he's the only one that can redeem you from the evil works that you've done, the bad deeds that you've done. It's stained on you. Regardless of what Islam is going to tell you, it's stained on you. Only Christ, through his sacrifice, can wash you clean. It's only through him because he's perfect. He was the perfect sacrifice and he lived the life that we should have. lived but we couldn't because we're not perfect all right let me ask you a question i haven't heard this before so if i just died yesterday and i didn't know this i would go to hell yes so you so you you said yes yeah because if you know that if you do not know that jesus you why would you go to hell because nobody told me so so yeah so this is exactly today yesterday i didn't know that and i could have been in hell is that that's a good question does that seem fair though absolutely so So the Bible says that every person, it's not that you are going to hell because you don't believe in God. You're going to hell because of your sin. As a human being, God has given us general revelation. What in Islam is called the fitra, right? The natural disposition. We already have a moral code. We know what's right and wrong, right? And it's up to us to either obey that natural disposition that God has given us or to rebel against that morality. We have that choice. And so if you choose. to rebel against what God has given you, that moral compass, then you are living in sin and you will be judged accordingly. So when you are introduced to Christ, which God does, he gives everyone a chance. I don't think that there's not a single person that he doesn't let. Yesterday, I didn't know what I know today. That's why God allowed you to live to hear this. That's why God allowed you to live to hear this. That's exactly what I'm trying to say, that unless you're not going to know the God or Jesus, you're never going to die. Because the Bible says that everybody will know my name. Okay, listen. You could say that that's why you're here today. Absolutely. What about the thousand people who didn't hear this message who died? We know there's people. I don't believe that there's people that God allows to go without a chance. I personally know people back home who never heard this and died. Really? They never heard of Jesus and the Messiah and him dying for their sins? Well, you could just hear Jesus, but what is that saying? What if I just hear Jesus? But you know for a fact that they never heard that Jesus died. died for their sins and they rejected it. That they never heard this message before. That Jesus died for their sins. And you know that, but I don't know why you know that. No, I don't. People that who never heard this message. I don't. I mean, we have the internet. It's everywhere. Is this you guys' first time hearing this? No. Okay, so the people like, let's say, like, people who live in the middle of nowhere who have like, have like sheaves and like camels and stuff like that that live in that lifestyle that don't have like the Bible as a book at their house who died. Who never heard of Jesus. Yeah, who never heard of Jesus or Allah or just like God. Like, what happens to God? Yeah, so, like, for example, is what you just said. I don't, I believe that God gives everyone a chance for revelation. Everyone, at some point in their life. I don't know, we're not there in every moment of their lives, so we don't know what they rejected or denied. We don't know how God dealt with that person. But the Bible says that He has shown Himself to everyone, that He gives a general revelation. We look at creation, we look at ourselves, we know that there's one God that exists. So then everyone hears it. able to so you said one God that exists yeah so there's Jesus and then there's Father and stuff Father, Son, Holy Spirit the one God but you're saying three words so we could break this down we could break this down easily but I want to get to it you said the Bible the Bible says that God gives everybody the chance the general revelation to know of his name before they die but the truth is but the reality is that's not true I don't that's not the reality I don't I don't believe that because hold on if you know anybody who's saying that they don't know ah them just going out Have you ever heard the name of Jesus? Well, I know kids don't know that shit. Kids? We all know, yeah. Kids? Yeah. Which kids are you talking about? Kids, like kids, young kids. Kids, man, that's different. We're talking about adults, man. So what do you believe about kids? They're going to heaven, they're innocent. Jesus says that the kingdom of heaven... Jesus said, let me tell you. Jesus said... Kids, before they know the right and wrong, they will go to heaven. But that's not according to Islam. Yes, there is. Okay, so let's do this, let's do this. Do you believe that it will be wrong if God were to... to send a child to hell yes okay send a child to hell but he wouldn't though okay so what if i would he literally says specifically like like if if the kid is not at the age to know between wrong and right it doesn't it doesn't say that guys so what i'm going to show you i'm going to show you where muhammad taught that allah creates certain people for heaven and hell and even if they're a child if allah created them for hell they're going to hell So let me show you guys this, okay? This is in another Sahih narration, I promise you guys. Okay? So let's see here. Let me guys get you this. This blew my mind when I saw it. So this is Sahih Muslim 2662C. So this is one of the, it's literally the second book under Sahih Abu Qari. It's authentic, right? So it says, Aisha, the mother of the believers, said that Allah's messenger was called to lead. the funeral prayer of a child of the Ansar. I said, so this is Aisha talking, right? Allah's messenger, there is happiness for this child who is a bird from the birds of paradise, for it committed no sin, nor has he reached the age when one can commit sin. So Aisha thinks the child's going straight to heaven. He's innocent, right? He's too young. Muhammad replies, he says, Aisha, peradventure, hold on, stop. He says... it may be otherwise. Muhammad. So, she's talking to Muhammad, right? She's talking to the messenger of Allah over here. Then it says, he said, Aisha, per adventure, that means stop, hold on, don't say that. It may be otherwise because God created for paradise those who are fit for it while they were yet in their father's loins and created for hell. those who are to go to hell, he created them for hell while they were in their father's loins. So before they did anything... He created them for hell. For hell. That means I created you with the purpose you're going to hell. No chance. It doesn't matter what you do. You're going to go to hell. I created you for this. And another person, he created them for paradise. They're going to go to paradise regardless. I believe this is a dream of the body, but how do I know this is... This is Sahih Muslim, bro. I can give you, if you want... The real book? I don't have the book. I don't know how the real book looks like. I don't... All you got to do? All you got to do? I know that verse. Yeah. So all you got to do is look it up, bro. Look up. It might be like misunderstanding because I heard when the child is in the womb, God knows where he's going to go. Yeah, but there's a difference between me knowing something and then me making you for a particular purpose. Right? If I know your purpose, that's fine. But me forming where you're going to go, that's different. That's me actively. putting my will onto you. But I've been taught the opposite. I know. So that's the point. That was a good point that you just said. You've been taught the opposite, which is why we're here. Oh my God. Logic.