Lecture by Deborah

Jul 8, 2024

Lecture by Deborah (with mention of Harvey)

Introduction

  • Deborah is an anthropologist with a background close to science.
  • Transitioned from Natural Sciences to anthropology.
  • Over 40 years, noticed art moving closer to her work, while science moved further away.

Main Theme

  • Art has taken over the role of radical ecological awareness from science.
  • Importance of observing and understanding human evolution and relations with the environment.

Concept of Data

  • Original meaning: Datum means "a thing given" (from Latin 'datare' - to give).
  • Anthropology and social life involve the give and take of gifts (reciprocity).
  • Contemporary science sees data as something to be extracted, not given (data mining).

Science and Objectivity

  • Science views data quantitatively; often seen as mining and extracting information (breaking data off from processes of life).
  • Anthropologists talk about qualitative data as well. Deborah argues that qualitative data is contradictory and can be unethical (turning back on the subject when converting perceptions into data).

Big Data and Neoliberal Economy

  • Big data proliferates alongside a neoliberal economy where knowledge becomes a disposable commodity.
  • Truth in data economics shifts towards impact and utility rather than actual truth.

Analogy of Hard Ball vs. Soft Ball

  • Scientists often use a