Controversy Surrounding Disney's Snow White

Aug 20, 2024

Lecture Notes on Disney's Snow White Controversy

Overview

  • Recent release of the trailer for Disney's Snow White has caused significant backlash.
  • The project has faced criticism on multiple fronts leading to a delayed release.

Key Points of Criticism

  • Leaked Photographs: Initial images received negative feedback.
  • Modernization Attempts: The film's premise is updated to appeal to modern audiences, causing resentment among fans of the original.
  • Actress Interviews: Lead actress Rachel Zegler's interviews have drawn criticism for being unpleasant.
  • Casting Decisions: Controversial choice to not cast dwarf actors to avoid offending others.

Trailer Release and Reaction

  • Disney released the trailer at the D23 Expo after a year of silence amidst backlash.
  • Visual Style: Trailer characterized by bright, overwhelming colors and CGI animals that appear unnatural.
  • Character Representation: Notable absence of traditional Prince Charming character.
  • The depiction of the dwarves has been labeled as "nightmare fuel" due to their unrealistic animation.

Issues with Production Choices

  • Physical vs. CGI: Critique on the decision to use CGI instead of real actors, suggesting that real performers would have provided a more natural interaction with Zegler.
  • Acting Concerns: Zegler's acting criticized for potentially involving her performing in empty spaces, undermining her performance.

Actress's Public Image

  • Zegler's public persona has shifted, possibly influenced by backlash against her comments.
  • Comparison of her demeanor in interviews shows a change in approach and tone.

Storyline and Character Dynamics

  • Central conflict regarding the evil stepmother's jealousy lacks clarity.
  • Comparison of beauty between characters (Gal Gadot as the stepmother vs. Zegler as Snow White) is problematic for audience perception.

Modern Adaptations of Classic Songs

  • New version of the "Whistle While You Work" song has been criticized for altering the message.
  • Original portrayal of Snow White as respectful and appreciative has been replaced with a more modern, independent stance.
  • Changes reflect a conflict between traditional storytelling and modern identity politics.

Conclusion

  • The trailer does not seem to improve public perception of Snow White.
  • The suggestion that Disney might consider dropping the project for financial reasons due to the overwhelmingly negative response.

Final Thoughts

  • Overall, the lecture paints a picture of a film fraught with controversy and dissatisfaction, suggesting that Disney's attempts at modernization may not resonate well with audiences.