Foucault, Nietzsche, and Genealogy

Introduction

• Speaker discusses Foucault's 1977 text: "Nietzsche, Genealogy, and History"
• Focus: Introduction to part of Foucault's method and Nietzsche's influence on him
• Goal: Understand genealogical approach vs. traditional historical method

What is Genealogy?

• Genealogy: History of our attitudes and dispositions
• Purpose: Uncover how attitudes and practices have changed over time
• Contrast: Not an inevitable linear progression but contingent
• Examined Areas: Attitudes, beliefs, morality, discipline, sexuality

Nietzsche's Influence on Foucault

• Nietzsche's Key Idea: Morality and other concepts have history, not inherent
• Origins (Ursprung): Attempt to capture essence, but history shows no perfect origins

Foucault on Origins

• Foucault's View: No perfect origins; born from chance, conflict, and competition
• Quote: “Examining the history of reason, born from chance and conflict”
• Nietzsche's Idea: Man’s origins, once seen as divine, now seen through evolution
• Implication: Historical moments are a combination of accidents and intentions
• Genealogy's Role: Unmask errors and accidents in history

Nietzsche's Three Terms for Origins

• Ursprung: Generic origin
• Herkunft: Descent or stock, impacts physiology
• Entstehung: Emergence, complex and multifaceted

Herkunft (Descent)

• Implications: Determines aspects of identity, physiology, and behavior
• Quote: “Body is molded by distinct regimes, work, rest, diet..."
• Genealogy's Expose: Errors and impacts on the body by history

Entstehung (Emergence)

• Nature: Complex, dynamic interplay of interests
• Quote: “Single drama of domination, differences, authority"
• Goal: Understand how ideas or events emerge from complex dynamics

Foucault's Critique on Historians

• Historians' Claim: Objective, valueless, unbiased view
• Foucault's Critique: Cannot be above history, must acknowledge biases
• Objective Historians: View history as continuous, logical, accessible truths
• New Historical Sense: Acknowledge complexity of causality and origin

Great Man Theory Critique

• History's Traditional View: Great figures control the course of history
• Foucault's View: Reject this, acknowledge plurality of influences
• Identity: Not inherited or inevitable, but multiple and complex
• New Understanding: Recognize and reinterpret the past, reshaping for the future

Conclusion and Appeal

• Speaker's Personal Note: Commits to making educational videos full-time
• Request: Support via Patreon to continue the work
• Member Benefits: Early access, inclusion in credits, access to scripts and audio
• Call to Action: Like, subscribe, and share the videos

Key Takeaways

• Genealogy is about uncovering the contingent nature of historical attitudes
• Both Foucault and Nietzsche challenge the idea of linear historical progression
• History is complex, dynamic, and made up of varied influences and accidents
• Importance of recognizing biases and subjective influences in historical analysis