Impact of Plessy v. Ferguson Explained

Apr 7, 2025

Crash Course Black American History: Plessy v. Ferguson

Introduction

  • Speaker: Clint Smith
  • Focus on legal cases used to oppress and liberate Black Americans.
  • Law isn't neutral; historically used to maintain Black Americans as second-class citizens.
  • Discussion on the landmark Supreme Court case: Plessy v. Ferguson (1896).

Plessy v. Ferguson Overview

  • Established and formalized racial segregation in America.
  • Allowed Black and White Americans to be kept separate under the false premise of equal facilities.
  • Legitimized racist laws in Southern states.

Background of the Case

  • Homer Plessy: Shoemaker, 1/8 Black, involved in activism.
  • Reflects "one-drop rule" - a social construct to maintain power demarcations.
  • New Orleans had a multiracial society with a significant free Black population.

The Separate Car Act

  • Separate Car Act of 1890: Segregated railroad cars by race in Louisiana.
  • Black activists in New Orleans, including Plessy, challenged this law.
  • Committee of Citizens: Organized a protest using Plessy as a test case.
  • Plan: Plessy arrested for sitting in "Whites Only" car to challenge the law in court.

The Supreme Court Case

  • Court Appeal: Plessy's case progressed to the Supreme Court.
  • Plessy's lawyers argued it violated the 13th and 14th Amendments.
    • 13th Amendment: Abolished slavery.
    • 14th Amendment: Provided citizenship and equal protection.
  • The court argued separation didn’t imply inferiority.

Court Decision and Impact

  • Decision: 7-1 in favor of Ferguson, upholding Louisiana’s segregation law.
  • Justice Henry Brown: Separation is not a badge of inferiority.
  • Justice John Marshall Harlan: Dissented, constitution should be colorblind.
  • Legalized segregation and humiliation of Black Americans; began the Jim Crow era.

Consequences and Reflection

  • Supreme Court failed a moral test; protected white supremacy through segregation.
  • Facilities for Black Americans were inferior, perpetuating inequality.
  • Importance of understanding the judicial system's role in shaping social landscape.
  • Call for future change towards justice and equality.

Conclusion

  • The Plessy v. Ferguson case serves as a reminder of the judicial system's impact.
  • Future possibilities for enacting laws and rulings centered on justice and equity.

Thank you for watching Crash Course Black American History. See you next time.