🇲🇽

Myths and Realities of the Grito de Dolores

Apr 8, 2025

Cry of Dolores: Myths and Truths

Introduction

  • Date of celebration: September 15th.
  • Historical event: Commemoration of Mexico's independence from the Spanish crown in 1810.
  • Key figure: Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla, who called for rebellion in Dolores, Guanajuato.

1. Call to Independence

  • Miguel Hidalgo: Considered the "Father of the Nation" for his call to emancipate from European rule.
  • Conspiracy: Part of a group aiming to overthrow the Spanish viceregal government, led by Ignacio Allende.
  • Historical perspectives:
    • Mexican history books indicate that Hidalgo did not seek total independence, but rather the return of Ferdinand VII and the ousting of viceregal authority during the French occupation.
    • Carlos Herrejón: Historian who argues that Hidalgo sought absolute independence, supported by the testimony of Mariano Jiménez.

2. The "Cry of Dolores"

  • Historical debate: There is no exact documentary record of Hidalgo's words.
  • Contemporary versions:
    • Include mentions of the Virgin of Guadalupe and Ferdinand VII.
    • Herrejón, based on Juan Aldama's testimony, asserts that Hidalgo did not refer to the Virgin or the king in his cry.
    • Hidalgo delivered three speeches that day, mentioning the Virgin in the first one.

3. Virgin's Banner

  • Artistic representations: Hidalgo is depicted with a banner of the Virgin of Guadalupe, but he did not carry it during the "Cry of Dolores."
  • Real history: He obtained the banner at the Atotonilco sanctuary hours after the initial cry.

4. Date of the Cry

  • Actual date: It occurred on September 16, 1810, at 6 in the morning.
  • Change in celebration: It is commemorated on the night of September 15, possibly reinforced during Porfirio Díaz's government, although it was already done since the First Federal Republic.

5. Year of Independence

  • Bicentennial celebration: In 2010, Mexico celebrated 200 years since the "Cry of Dolores."
  • Complete independence: Achieved in 1821 with the entry of the Army of the Three Guarantees into Mexico City on September 27.
  • Historical commemoration: Initially, it was commemorated on September 27 along with September 16, but for political and ideological reasons, it ceased to be celebrated.

Conclusion

  • Miguel Hidalgo was executed in July 1811, and the fight for independence continued until 1821.
  • The celebration of the "Cry of Dolores" remains a central part of Mexican national identity, even though complete independence was achieved years later.