Lecture on Memory and False Memories

Case Study: Steve Titus

• Background: Steve Titus, a 31-year-old restaurant manager from Seattle, was wrongfully convicted of rape based on a victim's false memory.
• Incident: Titus was pulled over because his car and appearance resembled that of a rapist.
• Trial: The victim identified Titus as the rapist, leading to his conviction.
• Aftermath: An investigative journalist found the real rapist, and Titus was released.
• Civil Case: Titus filed a lawsuit against the police, but suffered a stress-related heart attack and died before the trial.

Psychological Science of Memory

• Presenter's Background: Psychological scientist studying memory, specifically false memories.
• Common Misconception: Memory isn't a recording device but is constructive and reconstructive, similar to a Wikipedia page.

Experiments & Findings on Memory

• 1970s Experiments:
  • Simulated accidents led to different responses based on wording (e.g., 'hit' vs. 'smashed').
  • Leading questions altered witness memories (e.g., stop sign vs. yield sign).
• Stressful Events:
  • Military personnel's memories were distorted under suggestive information during stressful interrogations.

Misinformation Effect

• Sources of Misinformation: Leading questions, talking to other witnesses, media coverage.
• Contamination of Memory: Exposure to misinformation can change or distort memories.

Extreme Memory Problems

• 1990s Phenomenon: Patients developed extreme and bizarre memories through certain psychotherapies.
• Investigation: Possible links to imagination exercises, dream interpretation, hypnosis.
• Studies on False Memories:
  • Successfully planted false memories in subjects (e.g., being lost in a mall, nearly drowning).

Ethical Considerations and Public Controversy

• Therapist Ethics: Cannot ethically plant false memories, but parents might use it for benefits (e.g., dietary changes).
• Public Reaction: Presenter faced hostilities and lawsuits for exposing false memory cases.

Impact and Conclusion

• Behavioral Effects: False memories can influence future thoughts and behaviors.
• Ethical Questions: The implications of planting false memories.
• Lessons Learned: Importance of independent corroboration for memory claims.
• Memory's Fragility: Memory, like liberty, is fragile and susceptible to distortion.

---

This lecture highlights the complexities of memory, the potential for false memories, and the ethical implications of memory manipulation. The case of Steve Titus exemplifies the devastating consequences of memory errors in the judicial system.