Decodable vs. Leveled Readers Explained

Sep 30, 2024

Lecture Notes: Understanding Decodable and Leveled Readers

Introduction

  • Speakers: Mary Newton, Amy McGovern, Jeannie Schapp, Linda Farrell, Michael Hunter
  • Focus: Differences between decodable and leveled readers, when to use each

Decodable Readers

  • Purpose: Designed to teach phonics and develop decoding skills by practicing specific phonics patterns and high-frequency words.
  • Features:
    • Words are based on phonics patterns that have been taught.
    • Subject matter is secondary to decodability.
    • Focus is on accurate decoding rather than comprehension.
    • Pictures do not provide clues for decoding.
  • Premise:
    • Students learn to read by focusing on phonics patterns.
    • Encourages the formation of neural pathways for decoding.
    • Comprehension is taught separately during read-aloud sessions.

Leveled Readers

  • Purpose: Used in balanced literacy programs, focused more on comprehension than decoding.
  • Features:
    • Predictable text with strong picture support.
    • High-frequency words and repetitive language.
    • Books are leveled based on word count, sentence length, vocabulary, etc.
  • Premise:
    • Reading is learned through repeated exposure to words.
    • Students use pictures and context to guess unknown words.
    • Focus is on getting the gist rather than reading accuracy.

Comparison: Decodable vs. Leveled Readers

  • **Decodable Readers: **
    • Develop accuracy and decoding skills.
    • Used for phonics instruction.
  • Leveled Readers:
    • Support comprehension and discussion.
    • Useful for developing oral language in ELL and low-language students.

Guidelines for Using Decodable and Leveled Readers

  • Decoding Instruction: Begin with decodable books until mastery of CVC words and advanced phonics patterns.
  • Language Instruction: Use leveled readers for developing oral language and comprehension skills.
  • Transition to Leveled:
    • Once students demonstrate decoding proficiency in real and nonsense CVC words.
    • Ability to decode two-syllable words and some multi-syllable words.

Additional Insights

  • Decodable texts are used for practice post-phonics lessons, not for teaching phonics.
  • Encouraging students to read with accuracy first and then work on rate.
  • Decodable readers should be 100% decodable at the beginning stages.
  • Teachers should discourage guessing strategies often promoted by leveled readers.

Conclusion

  • Decodable readers are essential for teaching decoding, while leveled readers can be valuable for developing comprehension and language skills.
  • Teachers should use the right type of reader for the right purpose to develop effective reading skills in students.