Understanding TBI in Criminal Justice

Sep 28, 2024

Lecture on Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) and Criminal Justice

Introduction to TBI

  • Definition: TBI is a disruption in brain function due to an external blow to the head.
  • Common Association: Often linked with sports and professional athletes.
  • Research: Speaker researches TBI in retired and college athletes.
  • Public Awareness: Growing awareness of TBI risks in athletes.

TBI in Criminal Justice System

  • Vulnerable Group: Inmates and probationers are significantly affected by TBI.
  • Statistics:
    • 50 to 80% of people in criminal justice have TBI.
    • Less than 5% of the general public has TBI.
  • Women in Criminal Justice:
    • Almost all exposed to interpersonal violence and abuse.
    • Over 50% exposed to repeated brain injuries.

Impact of TBI

  • Cognitive Impairments: Poor judgment, poor impulse control.
  • Cycle of Reoffending: TBI contributes to repeated incarcerations.
  • Challenges: Inmates often feel out of control and frustrated.

Colorado Program to Address TBI in Criminal Justice

  • Objective: Disrupt the cycle of reoffending by addressing TBI.
  • Collaboration: Works with state and local partners.
  • Assessment: Neuropsychological screenings to identify strengths and weaknesses.
  • Reports:
    • One for the system with management recommendations.
    • One for inmates with self-management suggestions.

Approach and Philosophy

  • Responsibility: Does not excuse behavior, aims to change perceptions.
  • Perspective Shift: From seeing behavior as defiance to seeing it as a deficit.

Success Stories

  • Inmate Support: Inmates seek advice on managing TBI.
  • Examples:
    • Vinny: Uses reminders and checklists, out of jail for two years.
    • Thomas: Uses a calendar and takes breaks, avoids contempt charges.

Judicial Support

  • Judge Brian Bowen: Advocates for understanding defendants' challenges.
  • Categories of Defendants:
    • Defendants who are feared.
    • Defendants who are frustrating due to missed commitments.

Case Study: Mike

  • Veteran: Had a history of severe injury and compliance issues.
  • Support Provided: Maps, checklists, vocational rehabilitation.
  • Outcome: Returned to work, graduated from Veterans Court.

Conclusion

  • Prevalence: TBI is prevalent in the criminal justice system.
  • Transformation: Program changes perceptions and offers accommodations.
  • Resilience and Responsibility: Highlighted through examples of transformation.
  • Community Perception: Encourages society to see affected individuals differently.