Understanding Federalism and Power Dynamics

Aug 20, 2024

Lecture on Federalism: States and Federal Government Relations

Introduction to Federalism

  • Federalism: Division of power between federal, state, and local governments.
  • Constitution established shared sovereignty.
  • Federalism is complex and nuanced compared to unitary or confederate systems.

Types of Powers

  • Delegated Powers: Powers given to the federal government by the states.
    • Examples: Declaring war, making treaties, coining money.
    • Also known as exclusive powers.
  • Reserved Powers: Powers not mentioned in the Constitution and are retained by the states.
    • Examples: Education, health, welfare, licensing, and police power.
  • Concurrent Powers: Powers shared by both federal and state governments.
    • Examples: Taxing, borrowing money, making laws, building roads.

Evolution of Federalism

  • Dual Federalism (Layer Cake Federalism):
    • Lasted for the first 140 years of U.S history.
    • Clear separation of state and federal powers, like layers in a cake.
  • Cooperative Federalism (Marble Cake Federalism):
    • Emerged post-FDR and the New Deal.
    • Federal and state powers are intermingled, blurring lines between their responsibilities.

Grants and Federal Power

  • Categorical Grants:
    • Federal money given for specific purposes.
    • Congress dictates the use of funds, increasing federal power.
    • Often comes with conditions of aid (e.g., raising drinking age to 21).
  • Mandates:
    • Orders that states must comply with, funded or unfunded.
    • Example: Americans with Disabilities Act requiring accessibility improvements.
  • Block Grants:
    • Federal funds for broader purposes, allowing states more discretion.
  • Revenue Sharing:
    • No longer exists.
    • Federal money given with no strings attached.

Trade-Offs Between State and Federal Relations

  • Federal government uses grants to gain leverage in areas not constitutionally under its control (e.g., education, health, welfare).
  • States benefit from spending federal money without raising taxes but must adhere to federal conditions, losing some autonomy.

Conclusion

  • The federal government's power has evolved over time, often at the expense of state autonomy.
  • The next topic will explore further how federal power has grown over states.

Resources

  • Consider checking out the ultimate review packet for more insights into unit one.
  • Stay tuned for the next video to learn about additional federal power dynamics.