🧠

Evaluating the Multi-Store Model of Memory

May 18, 2025

Lecture on the Multi-Store Model of Memory

Introduction

  • Part three of a series exploring the multi-store model of memory
  • Previous videos covered the structure, processes, coding capacity, and duration
  • Current focus: Evaluation of the multi-store model

Supporting Evidence for the Multi-Store Model

Primacy and Recency Effect

  • Primacy Effect: Items at the beginning of a list are recalled because they are transferred to long-term memory with rehearsal.
  • Recency Effect: Items at the end of a list are recalled because they are still in short-term memory.
  • Middle items are often forgotten, indicating limited short-term memory capacity.
  • Demonstrates separate stores for short-term and long-term memory.

Case Study of Patient HM

  • Patient HM suffered from epilepsy after a childhood bicycle accident.
  • Surgery removed parts of the brain (including the hippocampus), reducing epilepsy but impacting memory.
  • HM could not form new long-term memories but retained short-term memory abilities.
  • Supports the idea of separate stores for short-term and long-term memory.

Criticisms of the Multi-Store Model

Artificial Tasks in Lab Experiments

  • Research often involves tasks not representative of everyday memory use.
  • Example: Peterson and Peterson's trigram study with counting backwards is atypical.
  • Results may lack ecological validity, limiting generalization to real-world settings.

Oversimplification of Long-Term Memory

  • The model treats long-term memory as a single entity.
  • Further research identifies multiple components:
    • Procedural Memories: Actions and motor skills (e.g., tying shoelaces).
    • Episodic Memories: Personal experiences (e.g., last birthday).
    • Semantic Memories: Knowledge and facts (e.g., capital of Sweden).
  • Model's lack of detail undermines comprehensive explanation of memory.

Oversimplification of Short-Term Memory

  • Evidence suggests multiple components in short-term memory.
  • Case Study of KF:
    • Motorcycle accident led to impaired verbal short-term memory.
    • Visual short-term memory relatively unaffected.
    • Suggests existence of verbal and visual components in short-term memory.

Conclusion

  • Limitations suggest the multi-store model is not a complete explanation of memory.
  • Upcoming exploration of the working memory model, emphasizing different short-term memory components.
  • Encouragement to watch the next video in the series.