Reflection on Gareth Southgate's Era as England Manager

Jul 16, 2024

End of Gareth Southgate Era as England Manager

Key Points

  • Gareth Southgate steps down after 8 years: Southgate's tenure as England manager has come to an end, marking the conclusion of a significant era in English football.
  • Reflection and legacy: Overall, Southgate is viewed positively despite mistakes; he is considered the best manager since Sir Alf Ramsey.
  • Fan reactions: Mixed emotions from fans, with many highlighting the best moments under Southgate, such as thrilling matches and significant goals.
  • Achievements: Reached back-to-back Euro finals, a historic feat for England, though some criticize his tactical decisions in pivotal matches.
  • Player development: Southgate played a significant role in developing players like Harry Kane and integrating them into the national squad.
  • Culture and team morale: Improved the national team's morale and changed the often-toxic atmosphere surrounding the squad.
  • Mistakes made:
    • Tactical errors in major tournaments (e.g., matches against Italy, France, Croatia).
    • Decisions on player selections and match strategies often questioned.
  • Impact on key players:
    • Harry Kane's growth and performance linked to Southgate’s persistent trust.
    • However, decisions such as only taking one left-back (Luke Shaw) who was unfit criticized.
  • Future considerations:
    • Debate whether an English manager should succeed Southgate or whether a foreign manager would be acceptable or seen as “cheating” due to England's financial power.
    • Eddie Howe and Graham Potter among the potential candidates for the next manager.
    • Considerations of whether Premier League jobs now hold more prestige than the England job.

Important Discussions

  • Foreign vs. English manager debate: Questions on whether the next manager should be English or whether hiring a top foreign coach would be better.
  • Impact of international vs. club football: Discussion on the current status of international football compared to club football.
  • Candidates for next manager:
    • Eddie Howe: Viewed as a capable successor but currently in a favorable position at Newcastle United.
    • Graham Potter: Seen as a potential though controversial choice due to his previous struggles.
    • Other mentions: Jurgen Klopp, Mauricio Pochettino, Lee Carsley.
  • Immediate expectations: Desire for the new manager to build on Southgate's foundations and immediately aim for success in upcoming tournaments.
  • Harry Kane's future: Debate over whether Kane should continue leading the line for England.

Conclusion

  • Gratitude and legacy: Southgate leaves behind a well-developed squad and a positive legacy, despite tactical shortcomings. The foundation is set for the next manager to potentially lead England to future victories.