Understanding the Israel-Palestine Conflict

Sep 8, 2024

Israel-Palestine Conflict Overview

Origins of the Conflict

  • Myth of Ancient Hatreds: The conflict is often mistakenly believed to be rooted in ancient religious hatreds, but it primarily stems from territorial disputes over the same land.
  • Early 1900s Onwards: The conflict dates back about a century, beginning in the early 1900s.

Ottoman Rule and Rise of National Identities

  • Diverse Region: Under Ottoman rule, the region was religiously diverse, mostly Muslims and Christians, with a small Jewish population.
  • Emergence of Palestinian Identity: The sense of Palestinian national identity began forming among ethnic Arabs.
  • Zionist Movement: In Europe, the Zionist movement emerged, advocating for a Jewish nation in their historic homeland in the Middle East.

British Mandate and Growing Tensions

  • Post-WWI Changes: The Ottoman Empire's collapse led to the British Mandate for Palestine, where Jewish immigration was initially allowed, causing tensions.
  • Jewish Militias and Holocaust Impact: Jewish militias formed to resist local Arabs and British rule; the Holocaust increased global support for a Jewish state.

UN Partition Plan and Arab-Israeli War

  • 1947 UN Plan: Proposed division of British Palestine into Jewish and Arab states (Israel and Palestine) and international status for Jerusalem.
  • War and Refugee Crisis: Israel declared independence, leading to regional war. Israel expanded beyond UN plan borders, creating a large Palestinian refugee population.
  • Post-War Territorial Control: Israel controlled most territories except Gaza (Egypt) and West Bank (Jordan).

Arab-Israeli Conflict to Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

  • 1967 War: Israel occupied Palestinian territories (West Bank, Gaza) and land from neighboring countries.
  • Camp David Accords: 1978 peace treaty with Egypt; return of Sinai to Egypt.
  • Shift to Israeli-Palestinian Focus: Peace with Arab states; ongoing Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories.

Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) and Hamas

  • PLO's Evolution: Initially sought all of British Palestine; later accepted land division.
  • Hamas Formation: Created in response to PLO's perceived secularism and compromise; committed to Israel's destruction.

Settlements and Intifadas

  • Israeli Settlements: Expansion into West Bank and Gaza, subsidized by the Israeli government, complicating peace efforts.
  • First Intifada (1980s): Palestinian uprising marked by protests and violence; Israeli heavy-handed response.
  • Oslo Accords (1990s): Attempted roadmap to peace, established Palestinian Authority.
  • Second Intifada (2000s): More violent than the first; shifted Israeli politics rightwards and led to increased security measures against Palestinians.

Current State and Challenges

  • Gaza Blockade: Israel's blockade after withdrawal, Hamas control, high unemployment.
  • West Bank Settlements: Continued expansion and impact on Palestinian life.
  • Apathy in Israel: Conflict seen as a distant issue for many Israelis; lack of political will for peace.
  • Future Uncertainty: Potential for further uprisings or collapse of Palestinian governance structures; recognition of untenable status quo.