⚕️

Medical Decision-Making for Young Patient

Sep 26, 2025

Overview

The discussion revolves around the medical care of 14-year-old Lindsay, who is married to an adult with legal consent, faces a cancer diagnosis, and must make significant decisions about her own treatment amid ethical and legal challenges.

Patient Background and Legal Context

  • Lindsay, age 14, is legally married to Reverend Cray with judicial and parental consent.
  • Lindsay's mother died young from ovarian cancer, and there is a family history of the disease.
  • Her medical emancipation through marriage grants her the legal right to make her own healthcare decisions.

Medical Issues and Treatment Options

  • Lindsay presented with pelvic pain and irregular uterine lining, possibly from a prior miscarriage.
  • She underwent a DNC procedure for retained miscarriage products.
  • She was offered cancer treatment options, including chemotherapy and was informed about possible hysterectomy only if her condition worsened.
  • Lindsay requested a hysterectomy as a preventative measure, despite recommendations against such a drastic step due to her age.

Ethical and Emotional Concerns

  • Medical staff expressed discomfort about the marriage and suspected coercion and abuse.
  • Staff debated involving police or family services but were bound by state law.
  • Dr. Manning advocated for Lindsay's autonomy, causing conflict with Reverend Cray and colleagues.
  • Concerns were raised about balancing personal ethics with legal requirements and patient care.

Hospital Staff Dynamics

  • Dr. Manning was removed from Lindsay's care after escalating tensions.
  • Dr. Halstead was assigned as primary physician.
  • Staff acknowledged the difficulty of the situation and the importance of supporting patient rights.

Decisions

  • Lindsay consents to a hysterectomy despite her age and pressure from her husband.
  • Dr. Manning removed from Lindsay's case due to unprofessional conduct.

Action Items

  • TBD – Dr. Halstead: Oversee Lindsay's care and proceed with her chosen treatment plan.
  • TBD – Monique: Assist Reverend Cray with discharge paperwork.
  • TBD – Imaging Department: Conduct head CT for Mitch Trubisky following concussion symptoms.

Recommendations / Advice

  • Lindsay was advised that a hysterectomy is not medically necessary at this stage and is irreversible.
  • Chemo was presented as the best and safest current option.