⚖️

Popular Sovereignty and Its Failures

Apr 23, 2025

Popular Sovereignty and the Pre-Civil War Era

Key Political Figure

  • Stephen A. Douglas
    • Senator from Illinois
    • Prominent political figure of the 1850s
    • Did not become President

Popular Sovereignty Concept

  • Developed by Stephen A. Douglas
  • Idea that people of territories should decide on slavery
  • Focused on western territories (e.g., Kansas, Nebraska, New Mexico)

Political Positions

  • Republican Party (Lincoln, etc.)
    • Believed Congress should prohibit slavery in territories
  • Southern View
    • Believed Congress must protect slavery in territories
  • Douglas' Middle Ground
    • Each territory decides for itself on slavery
    • Claimed to be a democratic approach

Practical Outcomes

  • Implementation in Kansas
    • Led to "Bleeding Kansas"
    • Civil war between pro-slavery and anti-slavery forces
  • Issues with Popular Sovereignty
    • Unclear who decides (first settlers or larger population?)
    • Uncertain status of slavery until a decision is made

General Reception

  • Popular Sovereignty failed in practice
  • Unacceptable to most southerners
  • Unacceptable to most northerners, who wanted to keep slavery out
  • Ultimately, it was seen as a national issue, not to be decided by early settlers