🧠

Exploring the Embodied Spirit Concept

Aug 26, 2024

Notes on the Human Person as an Embodied Spirit

Introduction to Key Concepts

  • Embodied Spirit: Central theme in the course.
    • Definition: Refers to the inseparable union of body and soul.
    • Materialization vs. Incarnation: Not just about spirit being materialized.
    • Human Person: Convergence of material (body) and spiritual (soul) entities.

Importance of Understanding the Embodied Spirit

  • Self-Understanding: Knowing potentials and limitations.
  • Unique Creature: Recognizing the union of body and soul.

Theoretical Context: Aristotle and Plato

Plato's View

  • Metaphysical Dichotomy: Body vs. Soul
    • Body: Material, mutable, destructible.
    • Soul: Immaterial, immutable, indestructible.
    • Body dependent on soul; soul independent of body.
    • Soul exists prior to the body.
  • Three Parts of the Soul:
    1. Rational Soul: Located in the head; guides other parts.
    2. Spiritual Soul: Located in the chest; associated with emotions.
    3. Appetitive Soul: Located in the abdomen; drives physical wants.
  • Myth of the Charioteer: Analogy for the soul's nature.
  • Conflict Example: Thirsty man deciding not to drink polluted water; rational soul guides actions.

Aristotle's Critique of Plato

  • Unity of Body and Soul: Opposes Plato's dualism.
  • Soul Definition: Translated from Greek "psyche"; principle of life.
  • Inseparability: Body and soul constitute the human person as a whole.

Levels of Soul According to Aristotle

  1. Vegetative Soul (Plants): Capable of growth, reproduction, feeding.
  2. Sensitive Soul (Animals): Adds sensation to vegetative abilities.
  3. Rational Soul (Humans): Capable of thinking; highest level.

Summary of Aristotle's View

  • Human as Rational Animal: Humans possess characteristics of both vegetative and sensitive souls, plus rationality.
  • Final Thought: "Man is a rational animal."

Conclusion

  • Understanding the human person as an embodied spirit provides a framework to discuss the relationship between body and soul, distinguishing Aristotle’s views from those of Plato.