Notes on Jill Soloway's Lecture on the Female Gaze

Jul 27, 2024

Notes on Jill Soloway's Lecture on the Female Gaze

Introduction

  • Jill Soloway (creator of Transparent) discusses the concept of the female gaze.
  • Topics include the male gaze, intersectionality, and female representations in film and literature.

The Male Gaze

  • Coined by Laura Mulvey in 1975 in her essay "Narrative Cinema and Visual Pleasure".
  • Defined as the depiction of women from a masculine perspective, presenting them as objects of male pleasure.
  • Three components of the male gaze:
    • The person behind the camera (director).
    • Characters in the film.
    • The audience (spectator).
  • Critique of mainstream media: The male gaze permeates much of film, TV, including genres like horror, romance, and action.

The Female Gaze

  • Soloway claims no one has yet defined the female gaze, so she is taking it on herself.
  • Challenges the notion that the female gaze is simply the opposite of the male gaze.
  • Misconceptions:
    • People expect the female gaze to merely reverse roles (e.g., women in traditionally male roles).
    • Examples: Magic Mike versus objectification through visuals.
  • Importance of understanding intersectionality when discussing feminism and media representation.

Intersectionality

  • Refers to interconnected social categorizations such as race, gender, and class, which overlap and create unique experiences of discrimination.
  • Acknowledgement that women of color and other marginalized individuals might not be represented within traditional feminist narratives or discussions about the female gaze.

C.I.S. vs. Trans Perspectives

  • C.I.S. (Cisgender): Identifying with the gender assigned at birth.
  • Calls for recognition of the C.I.S. male perspective in storytelling and creation.
  • Soloway stresses the importance of understanding the implications of C.I.S. male narratives and how they shape media.

Approach to Filmmaking

  • Soloway emphasizes a need for female filmmakers to reclaim the camera and create narratives that foster empathy and subjectivity.
  • The female gaze:
    • Part One: Feeling Seeing - Using subjective camera work to prioritize emotional experiences of the characters.
    • Part Two: Gaze Gaze - Showing how it feels to be the object of the gaze and exploring character depth.
    • Part Three: Returning the Gaze - Women asserting subjectivity and agency, encouraging a shared narrative experience that includes everyone.

Power Dynamics in Film and Media

  • Discusses how films serve to establish power dynamics, primarily benefitting C.I.S. men and perpetuating stereotypes.
  • How narratives can objectify women and separate them into binary roles:
    • The divided feminine – where women are depicted either as good (marriageable) or bad (sexualized, objectifiable).

Empathy and Cultural Critique

  • Advocates for the female gaze as a tool for social justice and empathy in storytelling.
  • Importance of recognizing diverse experiences and representations in media.
  • Examples of films that exemplify the female gaze include Fish Tank (Andrea Arnold) and It Felt Like Love (Eliza Hittman).

Conclusion

  • Soloway calls for filmmakers to embrace empathy in their storytelling and challenge existing narratives dictated by the male gaze.
  • Emphasizes collaboration among women and intersectional allies to build a more equitable industry.
  • Encouragement to challenge privilege and shift perspectives in storytelling.