The Gruesome Murder Case of Ryan Zimmerman

Mar 20, 2025

Lecture Notes: The Investigation and Case of Ryan Zimmerman's Murder

Introduction

  • A dog walker in Mercer County found human bones in January 2016.
  • Investigation launched after discovery of a human spine.
  • Years-long investigation reveals gruesome murder.

Discovery and Identification

  • Initial findings: Skeletal spine, no other remains.
  • DNA profile uploaded to police database, identity unknown until 2020.
  • Case connected to missing Ryan Zimmerman from Columbus, Ohio.
  • Ryan last heard from in September 2015, reported missing in November.
  • DNA testing confirmed bones belonged to Ryan.

Investigation into Roommates

  • Three people lived with Ryan before disappearance: Corey Buzzard, Sarah Buzzard, and Jyn Whitaker.
  • Police track down Sarah and Jyn in 2021.
  • Sarah and Jyn married, living at Sarah's mother's house.

Interrogations

  • Sarah and Jyn interrogated by police.
  • Police uncover inconsistencies in their stories.
  • Sarah initially denies involvement; later admits to choking Ryan.
  • Jyn initially uncooperative; denies involvement.

Evidence and Admissions

  • Blood found in Sarah's former car and apartment bathroom.
  • Sarah admits to dismembering Ryan, disposing of remains in different locations.
  • Jyn accused of assisting, maintains innocence.
  • Sarah claims Jyn orchestrated the murder.

Shocking Developments

  • Jyn's denial and anxiety during interrogation.
  • Jyn commits suicide during arrest at Sarah’s mother’s house.
  • Evidence of dismemberment uncovered in searches.

Legal Proceedings and Confessions

  • Sarah makes a second confession implicating Jyn.
  • Details of Ryan’s body disposal, including in public dumpsters.
  • Further interrogation reveals possible motive related to Ryan's gender identity.
  • Sarah sentenced to life in prison with possibility of parole after 30 years.

Conclusion

  • The case highlights complexities in relationships and crime investigation.
  • Ryan Zimmerman’s father expresses relief that no one can hurt Ryan anymore.