Raskolnikov's Dilemma and Confrontation

Aug 17, 2024

Crime and Punishment: Part Six, Chapter One and Two

Chapter 1: Raskolnikov's Wanderings and Key Events

  • Raskolnikov's State:

    • Wanders city in a mental fog, contemplating Svidrigailov's next move.
    • Encounters Svidrigailov at Sonia's boarding house.
    • Svidrigailov advises Raskolnikov on the importance of fresh air.
    • Svidrigailov has helped Katerina Ivanovna's children.
  • Interactions with Sonia:

    • Raskolnikov fears Sonia has been repulsed by his confession.
    • At Katerina Ivanovna's memorial service, Sonia displays affection by holding his hands and leaning on his shoulder.
    • Raskolnikov decides to confront either Porfiry or Svidrigailov.
  • Razumihin's Involvement:

    • Razumihin arrives angry, criticizing Raskolnikov's treatment of his family.
    • Dunia and Polkaria are mentioned, with Polkaria being sick with grief.
    • Razumihin confirms Raskolnikov hasn't abandoned his family for Sonia.
    • Raskolnikov discusses Dunia's feelings for Razumihin and mentions Porfiry's revelation about Nikolai's confession.
    • Razumihin, thrilled about Dunia's possible feelings, leaves.
  • Porfiry's Unexpected Arrival:

    • Raskolnikov is contemplating his next move when Porfiry arrives unexpectedly.

Chapter 2: Porfiry's Sincere Discussion

  • Porfiry's Stance:

    • Porfiry promises sincerity without gimmicks.
    • Suspected Raskolnikov due to his article and pride in his ideas.
    • Acknowledges Raskolnikov's attempts to conceal guilt.
  • Investigative Tactics:

    • Porfiry's strategies to extract confession from Raskolnikov.
    • Search of Raskolnikov's room and manipulation of Razumikhin.
    • Psychological speculation is the basis of Porfiry's case.
  • Discussion of Nikolai:

    • Porfiry describes Nikolai as immature, easily influenced, and part of a religious group.
    • Believes Nikolai might retract his confession.
  • Porfiry's Conclusion:

    • Asserts knowledge of Raskolnikov being the killer despite lacking proof.
    • Suggests confession could lead to a reduced sentence.
    • Encourages Raskolnikov not to waste life, insinuating a divine plan.
    • Gives Raskolnikov two days to confess before arresting him.
    • Asks Raskolnikov to leave a note if he decides on suicide, indicating where stolen items are hidden.