Exploring Women's Roles in Early Modern History

Aug 26, 2024

Early Modern World: Themes in Relation to Women

Gender Frontier

  • Kathleen Brown's concept: Meeting of different cultural systems of gender and nature.
  • Different cultures have different roles and understandings of women.

Marriage

  • European Marriage Practices:
    • Elite marriages for family and economic advantage (dowries, patrilineality).
    • Monogamy enforced by law; divorce uncommon.
    • Women could not generally hold property (coverture system).
    • Widows received a portion of estate due to dowry.
  • Colonial Marriage Variances:
    • Virginia Colony: Women could own land, had slightly more freedom than in England.
    • Spanish Colonies: Women retained property rights and had more legal rights.
  • Indigenous and African Practices:
    • Individual negotiation of marriage, sometimes polygamous.
    • Matrilineal societies, more flexibility in relationships.
  • Enslaved Africans:
    • No legal marriage rights, own ceremonies, no legal protection for families.

Labor

  • European Women:
    • Focus on domestic roles, but participated in market economy (e.g., brewing).
    • Distinction between societal ideals and reality of farm work necessity.
  • Indigenous and African Women:
    • Engaged in agricultural labor and domestic roles.
    • European perceptions of indigenous labor roles led to racial and status judgments.

Bodies and Cultural Perceptions

  • Europeans viewed indigenous and African women's childbirth practices and bodies through a lens of difference (e.g., lack of childbirth pain, breast-feeding practices).
  • Different masculine ideals (e.g., beardlessness in indigenous men).

Religion

  • European Colonizers:
    • Predominantly Christian, patriarchal structures.
    • Religious narratives affecting views on gender (e.g., Eve's curse, Mary's idealization in Catholicism).
  • Indigenous and African Religions:
    • Polytheistic, with roles for women as deities and priestesses.
    • Contrasting views with European patriarchal religious structures.

Summary

  • Key themes: Marriage, labor, religion, bodily perceptions.
  • Europeans used these differences to draw racial and cultural distinctions with indigenous peoples and enslaved Africans.