Kafka vs RabbitMQ: Stream Processing vs Message Queuing

Introduction

• Stream processing systems and traditional message queues serve different purposes in distributed systems.
• Using the wrong system can lead to problems.

Design Differences

Kafka

• Stream processing system designed for events.
• High throughput and retains messages for replay.
• Fan-out by default: each consumer gets a copy of each message.

RabbitMQ

• Traditional message queuing system.
• Queues messages until ready to process.
• Complex message routing capabilities.
• Messages are destined for one consumer (not fan-out).
• Handles moderate data volumes.

Consumer Patterns

Kafka

• Fan-out pattern: all consumers receive all messages.
• Useful for distributing events to multiple services (e.g., logging, analytics).
• Suited for smaller, unscalable jobs.

RabbitMQ

• Each consumer receives one message.
• Suitable for processing-intensive tasks.
• Can scale processors without issue.

Message Routing

Kafka

• Routing managed by the producer.
• Structure with topics and partitions.
• High throughput due to low routing overhead.
• No control post-production.

RabbitMQ

• Introduces exchanges for routing.
• Enables complex routing and fan-out.
• Consumers have control over message consumption.

Use Cases

Kafka

• Uniform messages, short processing time.
• Suitable for high throughput, fan-out scenarios.
• Use cases: Stream data analysis, event bus, logging, real-time communication.

RabbitMQ

• Long-running, complex routing tasks.
• Good for bursty data flow.
• Use cases: Job worker systems, microservice decoupling.

Acknowledgements

Kafka

• Uses offsets for message tracking.
• No explicit acknowledgements.
• Suitable for batch processing and tolerating message drops.

RabbitMQ

• Uses acknowledgements for message completion.
• Resends unacknowledged messages.
• Better for long-running tasks.

Conclusion

• Kafka: Best for high-throughput, event-driven applications requiring fast, fan-out message distribution.
• RabbitMQ: Ideal for complex, long-running tasks with sophisticated routing and moderate volumes.

Additional Resources

• More content available at interviewpen.com for system design and software engineering fundamentals.
• Coding environment and AI teaching assistant available.
• Community interaction and support on Discord.