Breastfeeding: Health, Politics, and Advocacy

Oct 23, 2024

Lecture Notes: 2023 Lancet Series on Breastfeeding

Welcome and Introduction

  • Host: Catriona Devereaux, documentary maker and science communicator.
  • Event: 2023 Lancet Series on Breastfeeding at the Royal Society of Medicine, London.
  • Focus: Unpacking three papers from the Lancet series that highlight politics, economics, and societal factors preventing recommended breastfeeding.
  • Key Points: Breastfeeding connects to health inequality, racial injustice, and environmental protection.
  • Reminder: Event recording available on the WHO website.

Presentation by Richard Horton (Editor-in-Chief, The Lancet)

Key Points:

  1. Contextual Issues:

    • Universal health coverage has shifted focus away from women's and children's health.
    • Need to revisit attention on breastfeeding as critical to child and maternal health.
  2. Commercial Influence:

    • Predatory practices by commercial formula milk companies harm children's health.
    • Highlights the exploitative nature of the industry as a capitalist issue.
  3. Child Mortality:

    • 2.3 million newborns died in 2021; breastfeeding can significantly reduce risks.
    • Urges support for breastfeeding initiatives in communities and health systems.

Presentation of Papers

By Nigel Rollins and Professor David McCoy

  • Paper 1: Breastfeeding in a Market-Driven World

    • Breastfeeding initiation and exclusivity globally is low.
    • Problems due to pre-lacteal feeds and lack of early breastfeeding initiation.
    • Highlights the biological importance of breastfeeding on health and development.
  • Paper 2: Marketing of Formula Products

    • Marketing is a sophisticated, well-resourced system impacting parental choices.
    • Formula sales are increasing, reducing breastfeeding rates.
    • Marketing practices influence health professionals and policies significantly.
  • Paper 3: Political Economy Analysis

    • Examines the formula industry's power over markets and health systems.
    • Discusses economic power and its effects on global health equity.
    • A call to action for stronger regulation of marketing and support for breastfeeding.

Expert Panel Discussion

Panelists:

  • Professor Helen Ball, Katie Gilbert, Dr. Goodie Singh, Alison Thewliss MP.

  • Infant Sleep and Parental Expectations:

    • Cultural myths about infant sleep and feeding need addressing.
    • Health professionals require better training to support parents.
  • Marketing Influence:

    • Misleading marketing plays on parental anxieties.
    • Need for improved communication about breastfeeding's unique benefits.
  • Political and Economic Responsibility:

    • Governments must enforce regulations and support breastfeeding through policy.
    • Advocacy for public awareness about formula marketing's misleading nature.

Actionable Recommendations

  1. Education and Support:

    • Increase breastfeeding education for health professionals and parents.
    • Implement effective support systems for families.
  2. Regulatory Measures:

    • Enforce stricter regulations on formula marketing.
    • Implement full breastfeeding support in health and workplace policies.
  3. Broad Advocacy:

    • Encourage public discourse and advocacy for breastfeeding rights.
    • Press governments and organizations to prioritize maternal and child health initiatives.

Closing Remarks

  • Acknowledgment of the importance of addressing commercial interests impacting child health.
  • Encouragement to use the Lancet series as a tool for global change in breastfeeding policies.
  • Final thoughts by Anthony Costello emphasizing the political nature of health and need for societal responsibility in supporting mothers and infants.