Dance Moms Uncovered: Brooke's Cheerleading Days

Background

• Focus on Brooke's cheerleading depicted in Season 3, Episode 3 of Dance Moms (aired January 24, 2012).
• Show presents Brooke as quitting dance for cheerleading, leading to backlash.
• Online claims suggest this portrayal might have been fabricated by producers.

Evidence Analysis

1. The Fake Tryouts

• Scene Details: Brooke tries out for a local Pittsburgh cheer team at Franklin Regional Elementary.
• Judge's Identity: Rumored that one judge, Audra Adams, was also a tutor for the Dance Moms girls, close with the cast.
  • Possible involvement in organizing the staged cheer tryout.
• Judge's Notes: Visible scribbles hinting at the pretense of the tryout.

2. Social Media Evidence

• Tweets: August 4, 2011, by Kaylee Cunha mentions cheering with Brooke.
  • Context: Season 2 hadn’t aired; Brooke had not mentioned cheer since Season 1.
• Further Tweets: Shelby mentions Brooke made the FCA Gems team but couldn’t participate due to the show.
• Photos: Brooke in FCA Gems uniform supporting the tweets' claims.

3. Timeline Discrepancies

• Tweet Timeline: Brooke’s cheer tryout mentioned in August 2011—post Season 1 filming but pre-Season 2.
• Cheerleading Season: Typically August-November; conflicts with show’s timeline.
• Abby's Claims: Abby accuses Brooke of skipping class in Season 2, Episode 1.
  • Suggests Brooke tried cheerleading during off-season.

4. Dance Moms Contract Constraints

• Initial Contracts: Originally 6 episodes, later extended to 6 seasons.
• Highlands' Experience: Contractual obligations forced participation; wanted to leave due to daughters’ disinterest.
• Legal Constraints: Producers threatened legal action if contracts were broken.

5. Producers' Desire for Drama

• Leslie and Payton's Audition: Created drama ideal for producers.
• Possible Strategy: Producers might have engineered Brooke's "cheer tryout" storyline for drama.
  • Suggested that Brooke took time off without actual cheerleading involvement.

Conclusion

• Evidence suggests producers may have staged the cheer storyline for dramatic effect.
• Brooke potentially used the time for personal activities rather than cheerleading.

Discussion Prompt

• Do you believe the cheerleading tryout was staged by the producers?
• Share additional evidence or thoughts on this issue.

---

• Next Episode Preview: More on Dance Moms contracts and behind-the-scenes revelations. Stay tuned!