Can I Laser a Patient with Cancer?
Dr. Phil Harrington, Laser Lessons from Dr. Phil
Introduction
- Contact info: laserlessonsfromdrphil@gmail.com
- Working as the medical director for a Class 4 therapeutic laser company for 15 years.
- Frequent and difficult question: Can a laser be used on a patient with cancer?
Key Topics Discussed:
Risk Management
- Logic of Decision-Making: Using the example of not punching someone in the face to illustrate multiple reasons for actions/decisions.
- Two Categories: Physiological vs. Medical Legal
- Physiological: What I would do for myself and family.
- Medical Legal: Protecting liability and license to practice.
Scientific and Physiological Aspects
Photobiomodulation Laser Therapy and Cancer
- **Studies Reviewed: Summary of current published research: **
- Selective cytotoxic effects of laser on human oral cancer cells (2015)
- Conclusion: Low power laser irradiation might potentially treat oral cancers.
- Laser therapy inhibits tumor growth in mice by promoting immune surveillance and vessel normalization
(Animal study with mice)
- Conclusion: In vitro increased cell metabolism; in vivo reduced tumor progression.
- Local immune response stimulated by laser treatment.
- Cost effectiveness of laser therapy in head and neck cancer patients receiving concurrent chemo-radiation.
- Conclusion: Morbidity lower in laser group; more cost-effective than placebo.
- Systematic review on photobiomodulation for oral mucositis in cancer patients.
- Conclusion: Evidence supports use for preventing oral mucositis in specific patient populations undergoing chemotherapy.
- Photobiomodulation in cancer: Further Investigations Needed.
- Conclusion: PBM therapy may benefit cancer patients; should be further investigated.
- Impact of PBM on patient-derived xenograft model of oral squamous cell carcinoma.
- Conclusion: PBM did not impact model behavior; indicates safety.
Medical Legal and Liability Aspects
- **Two Perspectives on Treatment Decisions: **
- Scientific/Real World: I would use the laser on myself or family, even over tumor sites.
- Medical Legal: From a liability standpoint, recommend not using the laser on patients with cancer due to potential blame if conditions worsen.
Conclusion
- Evidence shared, both scientific and safety perspectives.
- Personal stance vs. medical legal advice discussed.
- Final decision rests on individual practitioner's judgment.