Organ Trafficking Reality - Analysis and Insights

Jul 8, 2024

Organ Trafficking - Reality Beyond Horror Movies

Introduction

  • Topic: Organ trafficking and its portrayal in film and real-world existence
  • Observation: Body treated as a commodity by traffickers
  • Example: Patients like Garrett Row who has minimal kidney functionality

Garrett Row's Story

  • Condition: Dependent on dialysis machine
  • Health Issue: Kidneys have less than 3% functionality
  • Urgency: Needs a kidney transplant, on the waiting list for 2 years (average wait: 7 years)
  • Options: Legal system vs. underground solutions
  • Mortality Rate: Over 50% while waiting for an organ

Dr. Peter Chin-Hong's Insights

  • Black Market Prevalence: 10% known cases, possibly more
  • Reasons for Silence: Embarrassment, guilt, fear of revealing identities
  • Known Sources: Philippines, China, India, Eastern Europe

Exploring Trafficking Routes

  • Focus Area: Colombia, particularly Turbo and Medellin
  • Cartel Involvement: Clan del Golfo, a dominant drug cartel
  • Interview: Commander (cartel operative) describes organ trafficking in the region

Evidence of Trade

  • Migrants: Vulnerable population in Necoclí and the Darien Gap
  • Local Police: Confirm only rumors due to lack of political will
  • Interviews: Commandante and Ratero offer dark insights

Mexico - Systematic Black Market

  • Buyer Hunts: Anhael describes role in finding kidney donors
  • Clientele: Organ recipients, primarily Americans
  • Surgeons & Cartels: Close collaboration in organ trade

The Medical Black Market

  • Contact: Dr. Ángel describes compatibility testing for surgeries
  • Coercion: Instances of forced organ donations
  • Paloma's Connection: Involvement with organized crime and local clinics

Meeting a Recipient

  • Interview: “Juan”, a pancreas transplant recipient
  • Payment: Over half a million dollars for transplant
  • Ethical Dilemma: Would not have pursued if knowing someone was harmed

Societal Impact & Ethical Questions

  • Garrett's Situation: Reflects desperation and lack of legal options
  • Market Necessity: Efficient legal markets could mitigate black market existence
  • Ethical Reflection: Ethical arguments vs. survival instincts