🔧

Pine SEAL Soldier 9 Version 2 Review

Jul 15, 2024

Lecture Notes: Pine SEAL Soldier 9 Version 2

Introduction

  • Review of Pine SEAL Soldier 9 (Version 2)
  • Portable soldering iron
  • Higher power revision, runs at 108 MHz using Pine64 RISC processor
  • Open-source firmware for customization
  • Power delivery capability: 88 watts
  • Length: 17 cm, Weight: 20g (without cartridge), 30g (with cartridge)

Key Features

Display & Controls

  • OLED display: 0.69 inches
  • Two-button interface

Connectors

  • USB-C connector (Quick Charge 3 compatible up to 20V)
  • DC Barrel Jack (12V and 24V power supply)

Heating Capability

  • Uses resistive heating elements
  • Requires 24V supply for 88W power delivery

Cartridges

  • Comes with one cartridge; high power cartridges available
  • Some cartridges similar in length to Miniware ts101
  • Conical cartridge shorter in length, better design

Other Features

  • Accelerometer for wake/sleep functionality
  • Automatic OLED screen rotation
  • Multiple power modes (Power Delivery, Quick Charge, DC power)

Performance

Test Setup

  • Quick Charge 3 compatible power supply
  • Testing with a variety of PCBs
  • Measurements using power meter

Observations

  • Initial heating: ~40W, with fluctuations
  • Open air power draw: ~7W
  • Measured temperature discrepancies (15°C off from displayed value)
  • Calibration issues with the firmware
  • Performance with high thermal capacity PCBs was poor
  • Comparison with Metcal soldering station: Metcal performed significantly better

Cartridges Analysis

Differences in Cartridge Performance

  • Bundled conical tip performed adequately for general soldering
  • High power cartridges (2.4mm chisel tip) underperformed – insufficient power delivery (only 10-12W)
  • Possible poor bonding of temperature sensor in cartridges
  • Flat cartridge performed slightly better but still below expectations

Conclusions

Pros

  • Compact and lightweight design
  • Hackable and customizable firmware
  • Inexpensive and portable

Cons

  • Poor cartridge performance limits usability
  • Inaccurate temperature calibration
  • Limited variety of reliable cartridges

Recommendations

  • Suitable for occasional, light soldering tasks
  • Not recommended for high thermal capacity soldering needs
  • Miniware alternatives perform better, and professional desktop soldering stations outperform significantly

Acknowledgments

  • Sponsored by JLCPCB – affordable PCBs for prototypes
  • Patreon supporters

Final Thoughts

  • Viewer feedback and comments are encouraged