📚

The Rise and Fall of Borders Bookstore

Sep 20, 2024

Lecture Notes: The Rise and Fall of Borders

Introduction

  • Discussion of major companies filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection: Atari and Kodak.
  • Focus on Borders, a significant player in the American bookstore industry.

Background of Borders

  • Founded by brothers Lewis and Tom Borders in 1971 in Ann Arbor, Michigan.
    • Initially targeted college students with textbooks and rare titles.
    • Expanded to multiple locations.
  • Growth into a large bookstore concept with over 700 locations worldwide and 33,000 employees.
    • Emphasis on customer experience and knowledgeable staff.

Key Developments

  • Expansion and Growth
    • Opening of larger stores with a cozy atmosphere, classical music, and extensive seating.
    • Launch of Book Inventory System for efficient stock management.
    • Sales reached $32 million by 1988.
  • Acquisition by Kmart
    • Borders sold to Kmart in 1992, allowing for aggressive expansion.
    • Sales jumped to $1.5 billion by 1994.
  • Borders Group Formation
    • Spun off as a separate entity from Kmart in the mid-90s.
    • Innovations included in-store computers, coffee bars, and music listening stations.

Market Challenges

  • Competition
    • Fierce competition with Barnes & Noble, both chains approaching market saturation.
    • Estimated maximum market of 1500 bookstores in the country.
  • International Expansion
    • Attempts to enter Canada denied, but successful in Singapore, Australia, and the UK.
    • Overall sales reached $1.6 billion in the late 90s.
  • Digital Shift
    • Launched website in 1998, which was unprofitable and costly.
    • Lawsuits from independent bookstores and declining stock prices.
    • Partnership with Amazon in 2001.

Financial Decline

  • Losses and Failures
    • Significant losses reported by 2007 despite $4 billion in sales.
    • Poor investment in non-book products (CDs, DVDs) hurt profit margins.
    • Delayed response to the rise of e-readers (Kindle by Amazon, Nook by Barnes & Noble).
  • Operational Changes
    • Shift from full-time, trained employees to a part-time workforce.
    • Increased competition and decline in retail mall stores (Walden Books).

Bankruptcy and Closure

  • Filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection on February 16, 2011.
    • Immediate closure of 220 stores.
    • Ultimately converted to Chapter 7, leading to total liquidation.
  • Final Closure
    • All stores shut down by September 2011.
    • Some locations absorbed by competitors like Books A Million.

Conclusion

  • Borders' rise from humble beginnings to a major bookstore chain.
    • Failure to adapt to technological advancements and changing market conditions.
    • Lessons on competition, expansion, and maintaining brand identity.
  • The last remaining Borders location is in Dubai, while the original charm of the company has been lost.

Additional Notes

  • Mention of the video sponsor, "Symphony of the Sojourn," a new fantasy novel.