Evaluating the Success of Reconstruction

Apr 25, 2025

American Studies DBQ: Reconstruction

Historical Context

  • Post-Civil War South was devastated.
    • Infrastructure destroyed (roads, railways).
    • Southern economy in ruins.
  • Reconstruction (10-year period) aimed to:
    • Rebuild the South.
    • Reintegrate Confederate states.
    • Complete emancipation and ensure civil rights for freedpeople.
  • Key changes included Constitutional Amendments:
    • Abolition of slavery.
    • Citizenship for African-Americans.
    • Voting rights for Black men.
  • Resistance, especially in the South:
    • White Southerners used terror and violence.
    • Efforts for equality largely rolled back.
    • Rise of Jim Crow laws (segregation, discrimination, violence).

Prompt

  • Evaluate the success of Reconstruction.

Directions

  1. Read the main prompt carefully.
  2. Annotate documents and answer questions.
  3. Brainstorm using a graphic organizer.
  4. Write a 5-paragraph essay using documentary evidence and historical facts.
  5. Use the rubric to proofread and revise.

Reconstruction Timeline

  • 1865: Civil War ends, Lincoln assassinated, Johnson becomes president, 13th Amendment passes, Freedmen’s Bureau created.
  • 1866: Civil Rights Act, Ku Klux Klan founded.
  • 1867: Radical Republicans take over.
  • 1868: 14th Amendment passes, first African American elected to Congress.
  • 1869: Grant elected president.
  • 1870: 15th Amendment passes.
  • 1871: Ku Klux Klan Act passed.
  • 1872: Freedmen’s Bureau ends.
  • 1874: Democrats control Congress.
  • 1877: Hayes elected, officially ends Reconstruction.

Document A: The Reconstruction Amendments

  • 13th Amendment (1865): Abolished slavery.
  • 14th Amendment (1868): Citizenship and equal protection.
  • 15th Amendment (1870): Voting rights regardless of race.

Document B: Henry Adams Statement

  • Personal account of post-war freedom struggles.
  • Violent resistance from white Southerners.
  • Freedpeople faced threats, violence, and lack of recognition.

Document C: Black Codes

  • Laws restricting freedoms of African Americans.
  • Examples: movement restrictions, housing bans, meeting prohibitions.
  • Aimed to control and limit Black autonomy.

Document D: Education

  • Freedmen’s Bureau established schools.
  • Education crucial for empowerment and progress.
  • Desire for education contrasted with hardships.

Document E: Elected Black Officials

  • Many African Americans elected to office during Reconstruction.
  • Indication of some political success and representation.

Document F: Chain Gangs

  • Representation of forced labor post-Reconstruction.
  • 13th Amendment’s exception for criminal punishment exploited.

Document Set G: Modern Political Representation

  • Comparison of 2008 election results and African American representation.
  • Increase in African American congressional members over time.

DBQ: Reconstruction Essay Prompt

  • Analyze the success of Reconstruction.
  • Requirements:
    • Strong thesis with three subclaims (one counterclaim).
    • Five paragraphs (introduction, body, conclusion).
    • Use in-text citations for document references.