A Joker Review: Summary and Key Points

Introduction

• The review is highly critical of the film "Joker," directed by Todd Phillips and starring Joaquin Phoenix.
• Describes "Joker" as a film that fails both as a comic book adaptation and as a standalone movie.

Critique of Joaquin Phoenix's Performance

• Criticized for overacting and delivering unrelatable performances.
• Compared unfavorably to actors like Robert De Niro, Jack Nicholson, Heath Ledger, and Mark Hamill.
• Described as trying too hard and coming across as phony.

Critique of the Film's Direction and Style

• Todd Phillips attempts to imitate "Taxi Driver" and "The King of Comedy."
• The film is accused of lacking originality and failing to create an authentic Gotham City atmosphere.
• Criticizes Phillips for being a comedic director out of his depth.

Critique of the Plot and Characters

• Claims the plot is "nonexistent" and "adolescent."
• The portrayal of Thomas Wayne is criticized for being villainous and unrealistic.
• The twist involving Joker's girlfriend as a delusion is seen as predictable.

Criticism of Public and Critical Reception

• The movie is seen as gaining defense due to audience attachment to the Joker character.
• Critiques general audience reviews for lacking depth and objectivity.

Comparison to Other Films and Characters

• Joaquin Phoenix's portrayal is unfavorably compared to characters in Scorsese films like "Taxi Driver."
• Describes Phoenix's Joker as unintelligent, unlike Ledger's or Hamill's Jokers.

External Reviews

• Summarizes several critical reviews from sources like NPR, The Guardian, and Time, all of which echo the negative perception of the film.

Conclusion

• The review strongly concludes that "Joker" is a failure both as a film and within the Batman universe.
• Expresses a personal opinion that the film is "pretentious garbage."

Author Information

• The review reflects the personal opinions of its author, Aaron James Hills, and clarifies that it should not substitute for objective analysis.