Understanding Nutritional Ketosis vs. Ketoacidosis
Oct 31, 2024
Nutritional Ketosis: Origins and Definition
Introduction
Nutritional Ketosis: Defined to differentiate from dangerous ketoacidosis.
Historical Context
Over a century ago, doctors observed that individuals with Type 1 diabetes, whose pancreas fails to produce insulin, could not utilize glucose and overproduced ketones.
Ketoacidosis: Occurs with very high ketone levels, altering blood acidity.
Extreme levels can be up to 20.
Detected by smell, indicative of uncontrolled diabetes.
Nutritional Ketosis vs. Ketoacidosis
Nutritional Ketosis: Safe ketone levels between 0.5 to 3.
Results from a well-formulated ketogenic diet.
Ketone levels here are beneficial for feeding vital organs.
Ketoacidosis: Dangerous state with ketone levels starting from 10.
Total Starvation: Can increase ketones up to 7, but still below ketoacidosis levels.
Scientific Basis
Solid scientific papers show how beta-hydroxybutyrate (primary ketone) reduces inflammation and oxidative stress.
Benefits include optimized control for some inflammatory diseases.
Type 2 diabetes patients, overweight individuals, or those with hypertension.
These groups often have insulin resistance.
Insulin Resistance:
Body loses responsiveness to insulin which regulates blood sugar and fat metabolism.
Requires reducing daily carbohydrate intake to 20-50 grams (less than 10%, often 5% of daily energy).
Dietary Approach:
Not a calorie-restricted diet but focuses on satiety.
High fat intake is essential to compensate for low carbohydrate.
Moderate protein intake.
Safety of High Fat Intake:
Important to address if consuming more than half of calories from fat is safe.
Indicated as safe when following a ketogenic diet properly.
Conclusion
Nutritional ketosis is a safe metabolic state with distinct benefits and should not be conflated with ketoacidosis, a dangerous condition associated with diabetes.