Exploring Theories of Justice

Sep 6, 2024

Lecture on Theories of Justice

Aristotle's Theory of Justice

  • Aristotle's idea of justice focuses on enabling individuals to live rich, flourishing lives.
  • Good political arrangements should provide what is necessary for human capability.
  • Although Aristotle's vision wasn't inclusive of all people, the concept of supporting human capability is foundational.

Social Contract Approach

  • Emerged in the 17th and 18th centuries with philosophers like Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau, and Kant.
  • Inspired by the feudal context where opportunities were distributed based on class and status.
  • Imagines human beings in a 'state of nature', stripped of inherited advantages, determining fair social arrangements.
  • Influences popular culture and public life, fostering ideas like self-reliance and skepticism towards welfare and social democracy.

Critique of the Social Contract Approach

  • Assumes equality in physical and mental power, which is not always true.
  • Fails to address justice for people with disabilities.
  • Overlooks the physical and mental inequality present among individuals, including children and the elderly.
  • Calls for addressing these inequalities in theories of justice.

Capabilities Approach

  • Developed as a theory of justice focusing on inherent human dignity.
  • Emphasizes life circumstances worthy of this dignity.

Key Capabilities

  • Life: The most basic capability.
  • Bodily Health and Integrity: Health and physical well-being.
  • Development of Senses, Imagination, and Thought: Cognitive and sensory development.
  • Practical Reasoning: Critical thinking and decision-making skills.
  • Affiliations: Building relationships in family, friendships, and political communities.
  • Play and Recreation: Opportunities for leisure and recreation.
  • Relationships with Nature: Engagement with the natural world.
  • Emotional Capabilities: Living a life not dominated by fear.

Conclusion

  • The Capabilities Approach advocates for forming societies not out of fear but out of love and mutual cooperation.
  • Encourages creating a world that enhances the human condition and dignity.