Understanding Pre-tensioned vs. Post-tensioned Concrete

Sep 25, 2024

Lecture Notes: Pre-tensioned vs. Post-tensioned Concrete

Introduction

  • Presented by Tyler Lay
  • Focuses on the differences between pre-tensioned and post-tensioned concrete
  • Concrete is stronger in compression than tension
    • Romans used concrete arches to leverage this property

Prestressed Concrete

  • Modern solution to enhancing concrete's strength
  • Two types: Pre-tensioned and Post-tensioned
  • Discusses benefits of prestressed concrete in reducing cracks and enhancing durability

Pre-tensioned Concrete

  • Characteristics:
    • Involves stretching steel and then releasing to compress concrete
    • Common in repetitive structures like girders, beams
    • Utilizes high-strength seven-wire strands instead of rebar
  • Process:
    • Anchor one end of the strand, apply force (~30,000 lbs per strand)
    • Cast concrete around it, wait for it to gain strength, then release load
    • Losses occur (difference between applied and actual load)
  • Benefits:
    • Economical for repetitive use
    • Less concern for reinforcement protection
    • Improved durability and reduced cracking
  • Challenges:
    • Requires large equipment and specialized factories
    • Cracking at points of release can occur

Post-tensioned Concrete

  • Characteristics:
    • Used in slabs and complex structures like segmental box girders
    • Involves concrete with ducts filled with high-strength strands
  • Process:
    • Anchor one end (dead end), apply load at the other (live end)
    • Use wedges to hold strands in place
    • Losses are fewer compared to pre-tensioning
  • Types:
    • Unbonded: Contains oil or grease, anchors covered with grout
      • Can be adjusted/retightened if necessary
    • Bonded: Ducts filled with grout post-stressing
      • More prone to issues with empty spaces causing corrosion
  • Benefits:
    • Reduced cracking
    • Versatile in structural designs
    • Field stressing allows adjustment
  • Challenges:
    • Requires special equipment and careful design
    • Protecting strands is crucial to structural integrity
    • Risk of cracking at anchorage points

Conclusion

  • Both methods help reduce cracking and enable durable structures
  • Encouragement to explore further resources for deeper understanding

Additional Resources

  • Check out video on post-tensioning applications for slabs
  • Connect on Instagram: concrete.tyler
  • Suggestions for further topics are welcomed